[The Jewish Cunthead]

I might as well start it off with my possible keepers:

Hitters:
Jeff McNeil (23)
Vlad Guerrero Jr (23)
Dylan Carlson (13)
Mookie Betts (F1)
Alex Verdugo (
Randy Arozarena (25)
Gavin Lux (25)
Lourdes Gurriel Jr (9)

Pitchers:
Zach Plesac (25)
Marco Gonzales (19)
Corbin Burnes (25)

[DevSop]

Wanted to get this started since I am STACKED with keepers and want to make a few moves.

Here is a list of potential keepers:
Hitting - Dom Smith (25), Jazz Chisholm (25), Bo Bichette (23), Fernando Tatis Jr (23), Drew Waters (25), Mike Yastrzemski (25), Ronald Acuna (21), Ronny Mauricio (25), & Trent Grisham (25)
Pitching - Jacob DeGrom (13), Stephen Strasburg (F1), Triston McKenzie (25), Chris Bassitt (25), Sonny Gray (4), Grayson Rodriguez (25), Spencer Howard (25), & Tarik Skubal (25)


For most it will only take a pick in the 9-13ish range to get as they're a high reward potential but not great current value.
For those that played this year and put up good stats, we can negotiate (Smith, Tucker, Grisham, McKenzie)
For the 4 big names (DeGrom, Acuna, Bichette, & Tatis), there would need to be a serious offer and it'll be a big trade.

Strasburg is interesting and the discussion would probably include a lot of conditional future picks based on how he performs/how long he is kept.

The bolded names are the expected keepers but I'm more than willing to make moves.

[Attitude Adjuster]

REMINDER: Chuck traded for Lucas Giolito after the season. Assume he will be a Keeper.

[Road Warrior Shark]

Most of my keepers options suck. What else is new


Giancarlo Stanton (IL-NYY) - F1
Dinelson Lamet(SP-SD) - F2 - 9
Alex Bregman (SS/3B-Hou) - 17
Keston Hiura (2B-Mil) - 23
Nick Senzel (CF-Cin) - 23
Michael Pineda (SP-Min) - 25
Jake Croenworth (IF-SD) - 25
Travis d'Arnaud (C/1B-Atl) - 25
Ian Anderson (SP-Atl) - 25

None of them I am overly attached to. Leaning towards the 4 bolded and then either Bregman or Stanton. Sure as I pick one of them, the other will bounce back for a monster year.

[Road Warrior Shark]

Didn't realize Singer had exceeded the limits. Keeping him and Moving Bregman to F1 Status

Alex Bregman (SS/3B-Hou) - F1
Michael Pineda (SP-Min) - 25
Travis d'Arnaud (C/1B-Atl) - 25
Ian Anderson (SP-Atl) - 25
Brady Singer (SP-KC) - 25

[Attitude Adjuster]

My probable Keepers, with 2021 draft value. Gotta get rid of two of them.
Alec Bohm (1B/3B-PHI)--14
Ozzie Albies (2B-ATL)--19
Matt Chapman (3B-OAK)--20
Mike Soroka (SP-ATL)--21
Sean Manaea (SP-OAK)--23
Luke Voit (1B-NYY)--25 (undrafted in 2020)
Sean Murphy (C-OAK)--25 (minor league roster)

EDIT: Murphy is a catcher, not a pitcher.

[DevSop]

Feb 3, 2021 16:29:35 GMT -5 Attitude Adjuster said:

My probable Keepers, with 2021 draft value. Gotta get rid of two of them.
Alec Bohm (1B/3B-PHI)--14
Ozzie Albies (2B-ATL)--19
Matt Chapman (3B-OAK)--20
Mike Soroka (SP-ATL)--21
Sean Manaea (SP-OAK)--23
Luke Voit (1B-NYY)--25 (undrafted in 2020)
Sean Murphy (SP-OAK)--25 (minor league roster)

You should probably get rid of all of them and start over.

[DevSop]

Jan 17, 2021 18:52:13 GMT -5 kmacchuck said:

Here's my Updated list. Everyone but Gio is available..

Lucas Giolito 22

A.J. Puk (SP-OAK) 25
Anthony Santander (OF-BAL) 25
Alec Mills (SP-CHC) 25
David Fletcher (UTL-LAA) 25
Ke'Bryan Hayes (3B-Pitt) 25
Nico Hoerner (2B/SS-ChC) 25
Eloy Jiminez (OF-CWS) 23
Shohei Ohtani (P-DH LAA) 21
Trea Turner (SS-WASH) 17
Dylan Cease (SP-CWS) 16
Noah Syndergaard (SP-NYM) 15
Luis Severino (SP-NYY) 11
James Paxton (SP-NYY) 11
Gio Urshela (3B-NYY) 11
Will Smith (C-LAD) 10
Alex Colome (RP-FA) 6
Wilson Contreras (C-CHC) 4
Javy Baez (SS-CHC) F1

So, what you're saying is you need 4 keepers. I so happen to have 10 viable keepers.

[Lou]

I’m going to keep 5 of these:


George Springer F1
Walker Buehler 19 cost
Kenta Maeda 23 cost
Kyle Tucker 25 cost
Eloy Jiminez 23 cost

[DevSop]

**Trade**

I am trading Kyle Tucker to Irish for a 6th round pick in 2021 and a 12th round conditional pick in 2022 (IF Irish trades Kyle Tucker or keeps him for the 2022 season)

[Lou]

Feb 14, 2021 9:44:34 GMT -5 DevSop said:

**Trade**

I am trading Kyle Tucker to Irish for a 6th round pick in 2021 and a 12th round conditional pick in 2022 (IF Irish trades Kyle Tucker or keeps him for the 2022 season)

Yes sir.

[Lou]

I am trading Devin Williams and a 3 to Chuck for Eloy Jimenez

[kmacchuck]

Feb 14, 2021 10:22:28 GMT -5 Lou said:

I am trading Devin Williams and a 3 to Chuck for Eloy Jimenez

Confirmed - the 3 is for 2021 

[DevSop]

I updated my 5 keepers above. Going to keep McKenzie over Strasburg.

Which means Strasburg is available and getting a SP who is likely to go in the top 3 rounds of our draft...offers are being accepted.

[DevSop]

**Trade**

I am trading Dom Smith to Damus for a 6th round pick in 2021 and a 12th round conditional pick in 2022 (IF Damus trades Dom Smith or keeps him for the 2022 season)

[metstradamus]

Dom trade confirmed.

My five keepers are:

3B Nolan Arenado F1
3B Miguel Sano 14
SS Corey Seager 17
CF/RF Victor Robles 24
1B/LF Dom Smith 25

[dallasfanforlife]

Keepers

Freddie Freeman 1B-ATL (F1)
Juan Soto LF-WAS (21)
Tyler Glasnow SP-TB (F2-12)
DJ LeMahieu 2B-NYY (9)
Luis Roberts CF-CWS (25)

[Lou]

My keepers have been updated in my original post.

[kmacchuck]

Dinelson Lamet (SP-SD) F-1
Trea Turner (SS-WASH) F2-18
Shohei Ohtani (P-DH LAA) 21
Lucas Giolito (SP-CWS) 23
Devin Williams (RP-MIL) 25

[Sparty]

Jose Ramirez (3B-CLE) - F1
Kyle Hendricks (SP-CHC) - F2/6
Hyun-Jin Ryu (SP-TOR) - 12
Gleyber Torres (SS-NYY) - 21
Sixto Sanchez (SP-MIA) - 25

[Attitude Adjuster]

Finalized Keepers
Alec Bohm (1B/3B-PHI)--14
Ozzie Albies (2B-ATL)--19
Matt Chapman (3B-OAK)--20
Mike Soroka (SP-ATL)--21
Luke Voit (1B-NYY)--25 (undrafted in 2020)

[Army Dice Clay]

Keepers (with cost in parentheses)

Mike Trout (OF-LAA) (F1)
Gerrit Cole (SP-NYY) (14-F2)
Carlos Correa (SS-HOU) (15)
Dustin May (RP/SP-LAD) (16)
Kyle Lewis (OF-SEA) (25)

[ncs2009]

Aaron Judge F-1
Pete Alonso 23rd round
Clay Bellinger's son 19th round
Michael Conforto F-2 8th round
Blake Snell 6th round

As far as the draft is concerned, I never seem to get those right. So I will take 1st/24th and willing to trade down for additional picks, etc.

[The Jewish Cunthead]

Mikey’s keepers via text:

Aaron Nola F1
Zack Wheeler (20)
Zac Gallen (23)
Cavan Biggio (23)
Adalberto Mondesí (21)