[Evil Scotty]

so right now a 17 man bench is about average. so out of 17 rounds of the draft how many players should be keepers? and should it go by round or managers select there own keepers?

[The Canadian Content]

I think 7-12 is far too many. Four would be better.

As far as the round restrictions, I'm fine either way.

[The Jewish Cunthead]

What Fishy said. 4 seems like a good amount.

[Lucky]

Out of curiosity what would be the sense in 12 keepers? Wouldn't that just be the same teams over and over with 5 spots changing? And presuming those were the 5 worse players on your team wouldn't it just be about the same as if you had 17 keepers and just made add/drops? Seems like each year's draft would just be rookies and the back of your bench. Your starting lineups would barely change.

[Evil Scotty]

I'm just giving choices. I knew 12 was too much, but I just threw it in there.I figured 7 or 8 would be enough. I think 4 is too little.