[Lucky]

So in just about the must unsurprising or interesting Final Four matchup possible we have this. Trish pulled off some kind of miracle comeback over Christy which I'm just gonna choose to believe was orchestrated unfairly because I want to. Stacy knocked off Velvet Sky in what Dev labeled a WWE Bias win, but the truth is Talia/Sky had already knocked off #1 Seed Lita so she more than had her run. So now we got two WWE blondes who represent what some would call generic and cliched looks which won't appeal to half of our audience. And we're now one painful step away from the pathetically predictable result of that overrated sack of silicone winning the whole thing. Ah well.

Trish Stratus





vs



Stacy Keibler






Poll locks up automatically around midnight EST Sunday Night. Until then feel free to make any arguments you see fit. Pictures and video encouraged. No nudes, but you can link to them as long as you clearly label them.

[Mikey]

You'll need more than legs to knock off Trish, sugarbritches.

[Jack Quinn]

not with this guy, Stacy, easy

[DevSop]

Kill em both...PLEASE.

[BFG]

Really, hotness is completely subjective and to each their own. However....

[JayBee]

Not to be too snarky, but since when does one's rating of hot women have to be unpredictable or surprising?

I'm sticking with Trish here. Stacy is great, but having seen Trish on a lot of tv appearances since wrestling, I can honestly say that she is way hotter, and seems way fun to be around. That wins it for me.

In closing VOTE TRISH.

[Chris Eco]

May 19, 2008 11:10:49 GMT -5 BFG said:

Really, hotness is completely subjective and to each their own. However....

I agree, BFG. Stacy all the way.

[salmonjunkie]

May 19, 2008 10:24:57 GMT -5 DevSop said:

Kill em both...PLEASE.

I'd love to.


With my PENIS!

[Stu]

May 19, 2008 14:53:09 GMT -5 JayBee said:

Not to be too snarky, but since when does one's rating of hot women have to be unpredictable or surprising?

Yeah, this is the mindset about these things that's annoying?
Generally, if something winning is predictable, doesn't that usually mean it's because it's good?

[Lucky]

I think you guys are taking my comment a little too strongly. Its simply interesting to see underdogs and surprises. That's kind of a basic truth to life. Trish was the #1 seed so if she wins this thing certainly noone should be surprised. But its also not terribly compelling if the woman ranked #1 2 months ago is the woman ranked #1 when its all said and done. It was a simple comment made when I noticed that the Final Four was 4 of the top 5 women in the seeding. Such a result isn't necessarily surprising.

"Predictable" is simply often an uncompelling trip. The journey is sometimes worth it but there's a reason that "Cinderella stories" and "underdogs" become popular over the powerhouses.


Otherwise I'm just snarky because I find Trish to be terribly overrated and something you can buy off the shelf. So amazingly, I'm unhappy to see her get this far. That's not exactly a weird thing. Yes, there has been a regular habit in these showdowns that when they break down to parties that some people don't like they... say they don't like them. The alternative is to ignore it and stop participating. Which I have done with showdowns but which I don't have much of an opportunity to do here. So I made a snarky comment. I didn't realize it would offend the Trish fans.


EDIT: Ok, that's just a lie. I DID think it would offend some of the Trish fans because for years I've been baiting Trish fans with insults because she seems to have this really rabid fanbase that will argue you tooth and nail if you say something bad about her. So it was probably some involuntary Trish bashing that I like to do because I'm glad she's retired and off my TV. What can I say? I'm an ass.

[Tommy]

May 20, 2008 6:09:01 GMT -5 Lucky said:

I find Trish to be terribly overrated and something you can buy off the shelf.

Like you could only get Stacy Kiebler in some specialty store?

Abstain.

[bdbdbd]

May 20, 2008 14:53:19 GMT -5 Tommy said:

Like you could only get Stacy Kiebler in some specialty store?

Abstain.

At the very least, legs like that (connecting to an ass like that) are an added extra.

[Riot Act]

I'll give Trish the od here for her wrestling skills and what she contributed to the business as opposed to Stacy lacking in both those categories.

Also, I have never met Stacy but I have met Trish and she couldn't have been nicer, so +1 for that.

[Mikey]

Hey... where is Trish's first photo? That could sway some votes!!

[DevSop]

Could it sway me out of hating both of these women? I'm pretty sure no, and the fact that it looks like Gail is going to beat Mickie...I just wanna :cry:

[Eric O'Mac]

This thread is useless without pics.

[JayBee]

In the interest of helping out (some of these may be repeats)...










Just want to add that I think a Kim/Stratus finish would be awesome, btw. Should split this place right down the middle as everyone seems to have a firm side on that discussion.

[bdoriginal]

Not as firm as Trish's ass...

Despite evidence that Stacy does have an ass I wouldn't mind getting behind, Trish barely wins this one. I like both of their asses, so that's a tie. I thought Trish was overrated in the ring, and Stacy inconsequential, so another tie. So it came down to fake tits vs stick figure and fakes tits on a frame that looks athletic beats out stick figure everytime. I have a new appreciation for Stacy, but I can't actually vote for her over anyone I've cast votes for in this tournament other than maybe OBD. I can't remember if I voted OBD or not, but Stacy would have beat her in my eyes at least.