[Deleted]

Eric
Bull Durham
Raging Bull
Rounders
Remember the Titans
Forrest Gump
Million Dollar Baby
A Few Good Men
Wedding Crashers
Independence Day
Shrek
Mean Girls
Rush Hour
My Cousin Vinny
The Rock
Shanghai Noon
Cellular
Grease
Screwed
X-Men
The Great Debaters
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
The Fast and the Furious
The Mighty Ducks
Bang the Drum Slowly

Lucky
Tombstone
Raiders of the Lost Ark
Grindhouse
M*A*S*H*
Sleepers
The Terminator
South Park
Who Framed Roger Rabbit
A League of Their Own
Gangs of New York
Devil's Advocate
Cloverfield
A Christmas Story
Pet Semetary
Black Hawk Down
Stripes
Payback
Night of the Living Dead
Eight Men Out
Boiler Room
Big Daddy
Apt Pupil
Rosemary's Baby
History of the World: Part 1

[The Jewish Cunthead]

I love ya E but I just can't vote for anything having to do with ID4.

[Eric O'Mac]

Whatever. If you want to single out one movie as a reason to vote for the other person, I don't know what to say. I'd rather you point out something great Lucky has so I would understand your vote. He certainly has good movies. But thanks for taking the trip to negative town. I guess because it's baseball season, eh?

[The Jewish Cunthead]

Fair enough - The Terminator has been on Encore a lot recently and even though I've seen it a million times, I will watch it to the end no matter when I turn it on.

Also, Raiders and Tombstone are two of my favorites.

Sorry brother.

[Eric O'Mac]

I'm at least able to accept that.

[Lucky]

Wait... I won a Rd 1 matchup?

But I'm the 9 seed facing the 8 seed? In the 2nd Rd?

I am so confused.

[The Jewish Cunthead]

Beats me. I thought these were still Round 1 matchups.

[DevSop]

The "first" round was actually a play in round between the bottom 8 in order to make a nice round 16.

[DevSop]

And just for not realizing that, I'm voting for Eric.

[creepy]

Burned. I'm going with Lucky, but Eric has a pretty solid set.

[Lucky]

Apr 24, 2009 15:22:09 GMT -5 DevSop said:

The "first" round was actually a play in round between the bottom 8 in order to make a nice round 16.

Than this is the 1st Rd and that was a qualifying Rd. Unless we handed out 1st Rd byes to 8 and 9 seeds. And that's just a screwy tourney. What are we? The Big East?

Honestly, when I saw my name not on the last set I just assumed Gator decided "fuck it" and didn't include anyone who couldn't be bothered to send him a movie list. Which I thought totally fair and reasonable and even made me chuckle a bit.

[Lucky]

And you're not voting for Eric because of that. You're voting for Eric because I have MASH and other films recorded before 1980.

[The Jewish Cunthead]

E, I really do like your studio but you lost me near the end when you went with Shanghai Noon and Cellular. Lucky's studio was just a bit more solid the whole way.

I would watch 21 of Lucky's, 13 of Eric's.

[Eric O'Mac]

To be fair, I dropped those movies in the drop add period. That's not reflected in the list.

[Sportsguy]

Based almost solely on Rounders alone, I'm going with Eric

[Habs]

This would be a toss-up, both have great flicks and toher that I find to be... just ok (no real bad ones for me here). But Lucky has Payback, and that movie alone makes a big impact. I don't care what you guys think of it, I LOVE Payback.