[The Jewish Cunthead]

Quirky matchup here with Punker vs. Sop. Arrested Development or Dexter?

Punker



Sop



Legend:


Poll locks Tuesday, 10/27

[Sportsguy]

Closer than I thought, but going with Sop here

[Lou]

Punker with ACL, Taxi, Arrested Development, The Kids in the Hall and NewsRadio.

[The Canadian Content]

Punker's Thursday alone should take him far.

[Mikey]

Playmakers wasn't enough to swing me. Punker in a close one.

[Beer Baron]

Punker chose a bunch of that shows I would have taken if I was one pick higher in the draft. If you're not watching It's Always Sunny, you are missing a funny ass show. I also am a huge Dave Attell mark. Aside from Sop's toons, I've never seen any of his shows. An ex of mine just loved Dawson's Creek, and I really don't like her anymore. Sorry. My vote is for Punk.

[Eric O'Mac]

I voted for Dev on the basis on his Thursday. I'd watch his shows over Punk's show on Thursday, despite Punk having good shows. Throw in the other nights of the week, and it's about even. Just like BTR and Creepy, I wish I could vote for both, as I feel they both have superior networks compared to a couple of other matchups. Them the breaks though, and I'm going with Dev in a close vote.

[punk/core]

I don't care if you voted for him over me... but his Thursday over my Thursday? Seriously? I'd put my Thursday up against any other network's night of the week.

[DevSop]

Eric really likes Traveler.

[Sportsguy]

Oct 24, 2009 15:09:47 GMT -5 punk/core said:

I don't care if you voted for him over me... but his Thursday over my Thursday? Seriously? I'd put my Thursday up against any other network's night of the week.

Put me down for Sop's Thursday over yours as well. Alias and Dexter back to back, hell yes.

[punk/core]

I think Dev's network is good. And Dexter is awesome. But I stand by my statement.

P.S., I am drunk.

[Eric O'Mac]

It's not that I don't think you have good Thursday shows, Punk. They are really good, and I too, think it's one of the stronger Thursdays. But when I compare head to head, what would I watch if I had to choose between these two channels? I like Leverage more than Reaper. Traveler I would watch ahead of Get A Life and Newsradio (and I fully admit I'm in the minority here, but as Sop said, I REALLY like Traveler.) And as good as Arrested Devlopment and Always Sunny are, I'd watch Dexter first. The only thing I'd probably watch on your Thursday before Dev's Thursday would be Futrarama over the second half of Alias. And that's not a dig at your network. You have good shows. I don't think it's the best night in the entire competition (but I'm not a Reaper fan), but it is certainly very good and if you advance, the strength of your Thursday might carry you in that next match. But I just like Sop's Thursday more and based on the other 6 nights, I feel you are about even. Dev comes out by a hair.

[Lucky]

Punker's Thursday is just tremendous and his Wednesday is pretty good too. My problem is that from Friday to Tuesday the only time I'll even think of turning on his network is for SD. On the flip side while there's not one night on Dev's schedule where I think I'd sit there for a 2 hour or more block there is something most every night I'd be interested in. So 1 awesome night vs lots of scattered shows? I'm leaning punker but thinking about it.

[DevSop]

I'll admit that Punker's Wednesday is better here and that our Thursdays are at worst really close. But my Monday, Saturday, and Sunday really kills him. And depending on tastes, I really think my Tuesday is good.

I know better than to expect to do well here, but still. I remember stuff from last year and how shows did and a network like Punk's with all of the reality and game shows would have gotten killed. But now for some reason, a good night and a decent night is enough for him to win.

[Eric O'Mac]

Well, keep in mind, Dev, that even with my network filled with "1/3" reality, I still finished tied for 3rd. People complained about all the reality, but I don't think it mattered.

[creepy]

Punker----- Cartoons...........Sunday ends ok with the last two hours. Monday is paced wierd. Music, gay guys, dirt jobs and music. Don't like that Zimmern goofball. Never thought Dave Attell was funny. Extras is great. Thursday is good, but never seen Reaper and Futurama is ok for a cartoon. It's mainly those kidcartoons that turn me off. I'm drunk, too. Ninja Warrior's awesome. Wouldn't watch anything on Saturday night. Arrested D is one of the best shows on any of our networks. That IASIPhilly show............ I don't know. I watched an episode and hated it. Heard so many great things though, so maybe I need to give it another chance.



Sop-

Have no idea what some of the Sunday night stuff is, but cartoons=meh, and Kings looked boring and was canceled quick, so I'm guessing I didn't miss much and Castle sounds alot like Murder, She Wrote, but everyone hates that show, so I guess hot dudes make that show more enjoyable. I don't know.

Cartoons. Stuff I don't care about. Been meaning to watch Supernatural, but I gotta start from the beginning on that one and it better be outstanding for me to stick with it for as long as it's been on. Tuesday sucks, so does Wednesday. Watched the first Leverage and it sucked and I already told you about my feelings on that show last year and you said you hated me. Traveler and Alias are shows I've never seen. Want to start Dexter from the beginning, as I've heard a shitload of good things about it.

I'm not a nerd and Saturday is ok until Eastbound and Down. Just saw that last week and I fucking loved it. Got hammered on cheap beer and laughed my ass off every episode.




Dev might have more potential for me if Dexter and Supernatural are good, but I don't know, yet. I'll have to think about this one.

[creepy]

I, so far, have the tie breaker. So I'll go night by night. Most nights wins!


Sunday - Punker, because Coach and Taxi ore ok.

Monday - Punker, because of BTM and ACL. BTM is ok depending on who's featured.

Tuesday - I cannot, in clear conscience, vote for either night.

Wednesday - Punker, although Extras is the only show I'd watch on either network this night.

Thursday - Punker, based on NewsRadio and Arrested Development

Friday - I guess it doesn't matter anymore, but Punker, based on Ninja Warrior and Smackdown

Saturday - Sop, because EB&D is the only show I'd watch on either network.

[BTR]

Sop has some good shows, especially Pushing Daisies, but Punker's got more of my favorites.

[The Jewish Cunthead]

Punker moves on... great matchup.