The Winner's Circle
Jul 23, 2010 11:19:30 GMT -5
Post by The Canadian Content on Jul 23, 2010 11:19:30 GMT -5
2024
Wrestling Factions - Matte (8-3 Dev)
2023
Wrestling Supercard - Hodgey (7-6 Cole) and Eric (6-5 SG)
Wrestling Draft - Eco (8-5 DevSop)
Leftovers Wrestling Draft - Mayhem (7-5 Eco)
The Worst Draft - Incomplete
2000s Movies Draft - DevSop (4-3-3 Eric, Sportsguy)
2022
Wrestling Roster Swap - DevSop (6-4 Hodgey)
Wrestling Draft - Cole (6-5 Hodgey)
Heroes/Villains - Hodgey (4-3 Mayhem, 5-2 SG) and Cole (4-3 SG, 5-3 Mayhem)
USA Road Trip - Matte (6-4 Hodgey)
1990s Movies - Sportsguy (6-5 Solly)
2021
1990s Movie - Undeclared
Golden Ticket Event - Cletus & Hodgey (3-3-1 Solly)
Wrestling Draft - Leo (4-3 Mayhem)
Record Collection Draft - Solly (7.5-4 Hodgey)
2020 Olympics Tokyo - Eco (375-347 BC)
Zoo - Shark (5-1-1 Matte, Hodgey)
Monster Smash - Matte (5-3 Mayhem)
Movie Recast - Matte (6-5 Solly)
2020
Wrestling Draft - Mayhem (5-3 Hodgey)
1985 Fantasy Manager - Mayhem (3-2 Leo)
Stipulation Wrestling Draft - DevSop (6-3 Hodgey)
Ultimate TV Sitcom - Shark (5-3 Leo)
1980s Movie - Hodgey (6-4 Solly)
WarGames - Shark (6-5 Eco)
2019
All-Time Variety/Sketch - Solly (7-2 Leo)
PunTV Network - Hodgey (3-1-1 Dead, Sportsguy)
Expundables 2 - Solly (4-3-2 Mayhem, Leo)
TV Character Showdown - Incomplete
Anything Goes Wrestling Draft - Cletus (3-2-1 Hodgey, Leo)
GM Wrestling Roster - Mayhem (6-5 Eric)
Wrestling Draft - DevSop (6-5 Matte)
2018
Women's Wrestling Draft - Hodgey & Eco (4-4 tie)
Fictional Character Wrestling Draft - Dalem (5-3 Eric)
Wrestling Draft - Leo (5-4 Eric)
Punapalooza - Hodgey (2-2-2 tiebreak Mayhem, Leo)
TV Pitch - Sportsguy - (4-2 Mayhem)
Punnywood - Solly (85-81 Hodgey)
2018 Olympics Pyeongchang - AA (208-194 Dev)
2017-2018 Sports Franchise - Dev (8417-8057 Eric)
2017
Wrestling Rosters Booking - Hodgey (5-4 Leo)
Hero Draft 2017 - Lizzy (7-2 Mayhem)
Comedic Character Showdown - Al Bundy (6-4 Ralph Kramden)
Horror Character Showdown - Dracula (4-1 Hannibal Lecter)
Wrestling Draft - Lizzy (8-6 Eco)
Spaceship Crew - Mayhem (3-3-2 tiebreak Solly, Dev)
2016-2017 Sports Franchise - Dead (7093-6969 Shark)
2016
Movie Pitch 2016 - Hodgey (4-3. Sharky)
Pun TV 2016 - Hodgey (5-4, Solly)
Punnywood 2016 - Hodgey (107-98, Solly)
Wrestling Draft 2016 - Sharky (8-5 Matte)
TV Recast 2016 - Lizzy (7-4 Dead)
SNL Cast - Eco (6-3-2 over Smitty, Dead)
2016 Olympics Rio - AA (689-660 Dev)
2015
Wrestling Draft 2015 - Dead (6-4, Solly)
Survivor Series 2015 - Hodgey (5-4, Eco)
Survivor Series 2015 (Women) Solly (5-4, Eco)
2014
Olympics Pick'em - Firewoman (158-110, Dead) Medal points
2014 Movie Draft - Unknown
Wrestling Draft 2K14 Eric (4-4 Tiebreak, Hodgey)
Movie Recast 2014 Hodgey (3-2, Solly)
Heroes vs Villains Hodgey (3-2, Mayhem)
2013
All-Time Fantasy Hockey – Solly (5-2 Carlito)
Movie Pitch Draft – Fifth & Hodgey (Tie 6-6)
Sequeltology – The Dark Knight (6-4 The Empire Strikes Back)
Villan Team – Dev (25-22-19 Demko, Demko) *Ranking points
Survivor Series Draft - Carlito (9-6 Solly)
Hero Team - MayhemNX (19-16-13 Solly, Solly) *Ranking points
Hero Team vs Villan Team - MayhemNX (5-1 Dev)
Punapalooza - Hodgey(66-56 Solly) *Some unknown to anyone but Gator scoring system
Fictional Character Melee part Deux - Westley (6-5 Sergeant Hartman)
Movie Recast 2013 - Hodgey (4-2 Mayhem)
Superhero/Villain 2013 - Hodgey Villain (5-4 Hodgey Hero)
Build-A-Stable Draft - Dead (5-5 Tiebreak, Solly)
2012
All-Time Baseball Mikey (7-2 Shark)
Survivor Series Dev (5-5 Tiebreak, Dead)
Mix CD Draft 2 – Doug (6-5 Carlito)
Punnywood – Incomplete
Build-A-Band – Dead (5-2 Angle)
SuperHero/Villan Mega Draft Gator Villan (4-3 Gator Hero)
Wrestling Draft – Doug/Shark (9-7 Dead/Matte)
2011
Fictional Hero Megadraft - Sop (8-5 over Hodgey)
Wrestling Draft (Set Card) - Sop (9-8 over Dashbee)
Ho Down 2 - Angle (136 total votes)
Pun Box Live - Punker (5-4 over Hodgey)
Wrestlefest 2011 - EricOSystem (10-6 over Carlito)
Princess Bride Recast - Shark (10-8-4 Hodgey, Mayhem)
Superhero/Villan – Dev (3-3 Tiebreak Gator)
TV Draft – Doug (6-5-2 Eric, Solly)
CBM Comic Team Showdown – Incomplete
Movie Pitch Draft – Hodgey (5-3 Doug)
Superconference Draft – Incomplete
2010
Supervillain Team Draft - DevSop (10-8 over BTR)
Superhero Team Draft - Gator (5-5 over Jobber via tiebreak)
Survivor Series Draft - Dashbee (8-7 over Hodgey)
Ho Down Draft - DevSop
Punnywood Movie Studio Draft - Solly
Superconference Draft - DevSop
The Expundables Draft - Simmons (9-8 over Angle)
Mix CD Draft - Solly (6-2 over Gator)
Wrestlefest 2010 - Eco (8-5 over Dashbee)
Star Wars Recast Draft - Hodgey (7-7 over Stu via tiebreak)
PPV Supercard Draft - Mikey (5-4-1-1 over Eric, Dash, Thai)
PH Supergroup Idol 2 - Solly (4-3 over Lou)
2009
What’s for Dinner Draft - Pun (11-10 over Mikey)
Punster of the Year (POTY) - Solly (17-13 over Punker)
Punnywood Movie Studio Draft - Creepy (12-5 over Habsy)
Punnywood Movie Studio Box Office - Solly
Supergroup Idol Draft - Blitz (11-6 over Jobber)
Punapalooza Draft (Day 1) - Punker (12-2 over Court)
Punapalooza Draft (Day 2) - Hodgey (8-7 over Thai)
Punapalooza Draft (Days 1 & 2) - Punker & Hodgey (9-9 Tie)
90s Mix CD Draft - Hodgey (5-2 over BC)
Superhero Team Draft - Ziggy (8-8 over Hodgey via tiebreak)
PunTV Draft - Angstboy (10-10 over Eric via tiebreak)
Historical Figure Wrestling Alliance Draft - Incomplete
Sports Character Draft - Mikey (3-1 over DevSop)
Wrestling Draft - Eric (12-10 over Eco)
2008
Network Drama TV Showdown - LOST (9-5 over Heroes)
Tag Team Showdown - Hart Foundation (13-12 over Edge & Christian)
Hot Chicks Showdown (Sports) - Willa Ford (7-3 over Anna Benson)
Hot Chicks Showdown (Wrestling) - Mickie James (20-16 over Trish Stratus)
Stand-Up Comedian Showdown - Richard Pryor (17-14 over Mitch Hedberg)
Video Games Showdown - Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (13-8 over Super Mario World)
PunTV Draft - Solly (13-11 over BTR)
2007
Supervillain Showdown - Joker (10-4 over Dr. Doom)
Batman Artists Showdown - Neal Adams (9-4 over Jim Aparo)
Hot Chicks Showdown - Scarlett Johansson (12-10 over Jessica Biel)
Best Wrestler Showdown - Ric Flair (29-15 over Chris Jericho)
Kids’ TV Showdown - Looney Tunes (12-5 over Animaniacs)
Comedy TV Showdown - The Simpsons (12-6 over South Park)
Cable Drama TV Showdown - The Sopranos (7-5 over The Shield)
2006
Superhero Showdown - Batman (12-5 over Spider-Man)
W: Ties got 1 each since there is no Runner Up. Team drafts got .5 for each team member.
RUP: Some drafts had no Runner Up listed, while some had multiple. The multiples all got 1 since they made the finals, unless both Runners Up were the same person, then they just get 1. Confused? Good.
Obviously, the old-school showdowns weren't figured in.
OVERALL -------- W - RUP
Hodgey --------- 23 - 13
DevSop --------- 13 - 7
Solly ---------- 12 - 13
Mayhem --------- 7 - 9
Eco ------------ 5.5 - 6
Shark ---------- 5.5 - 3
Dead ----------- 4 - 5.5
Matte ---------- 4 - 3.5
Eric ----------- 3.5 - 8
Sportsguy ------ 3 - 4
Mikey ---------- 3 - 1
Punker --------- 3 - 1
Lizzy ---------- 3 - 0
Doug ----------- 2.5 - 1
Leo ------------ 2 - 7
Gator ---------- 2 - 3
Cole ----------- 2 - 1
AA ------------- 2 - 0
Cletus --------- 2 - 0
Dashbee -------- 1 - 3
Carlito -------- 1 - 3
Angle ---------- 1 - 2
Creepy --------- 1 - 0
Angstboy ------- 1 - 0
OpTard --------- 1 - 0
Pun ------------ 1 - 0
Blitz ---------- 1 - 0
Fifth Horseman - 1 - 0
Firewoman ------ 1 - 0
Dalem ---------- 1 - 0
Demko ---------- 0 - 2
BTR ------------ 0 - 2
Thai ----------- 0 - 2
Jobber --------- 0 - 2
BC ------------- 0 - 2
Habs ----------- 0 - 1
Courtney ------- 0 - 1
Lou ------------ 0 - 1
Stu ------------ 0 - 1
Smitty --------- 0 - 1
Wrestling Factions - Matte (8-3 Dev)
2023
Wrestling Supercard - Hodgey (7-6 Cole) and Eric (6-5 SG)
Wrestling Draft - Eco (8-5 DevSop)
Leftovers Wrestling Draft - Mayhem (7-5 Eco)
The Worst Draft - Incomplete
2000s Movies Draft - DevSop (4-3-3 Eric, Sportsguy)
2022
Wrestling Roster Swap - DevSop (6-4 Hodgey)
Wrestling Draft - Cole (6-5 Hodgey)
Heroes/Villains - Hodgey (4-3 Mayhem, 5-2 SG) and Cole (4-3 SG, 5-3 Mayhem)
USA Road Trip - Matte (6-4 Hodgey)
1990s Movies - Sportsguy (6-5 Solly)
2021
1990s Movie - Undeclared
Golden Ticket Event - Cletus & Hodgey (3-3-1 Solly)
Wrestling Draft - Leo (4-3 Mayhem)
Record Collection Draft - Solly (7.5-4 Hodgey)
2020 Olympics Tokyo - Eco (375-347 BC)
Zoo - Shark (5-1-1 Matte, Hodgey)
Monster Smash - Matte (5-3 Mayhem)
Movie Recast - Matte (6-5 Solly)
2020
Wrestling Draft - Mayhem (5-3 Hodgey)
1985 Fantasy Manager - Mayhem (3-2 Leo)
Stipulation Wrestling Draft - DevSop (6-3 Hodgey)
Ultimate TV Sitcom - Shark (5-3 Leo)
1980s Movie - Hodgey (6-4 Solly)
WarGames - Shark (6-5 Eco)
2019
All-Time Variety/Sketch - Solly (7-2 Leo)
PunTV Network - Hodgey (3-1-1 Dead, Sportsguy)
Expundables 2 - Solly (4-3-2 Mayhem, Leo)
TV Character Showdown - Incomplete
Anything Goes Wrestling Draft - Cletus (3-2-1 Hodgey, Leo)
GM Wrestling Roster - Mayhem (6-5 Eric)
Wrestling Draft - DevSop (6-5 Matte)
2018
Women's Wrestling Draft - Hodgey & Eco (4-4 tie)
Fictional Character Wrestling Draft - Dalem (5-3 Eric)
Wrestling Draft - Leo (5-4 Eric)
Punapalooza - Hodgey (2-2-2 tiebreak Mayhem, Leo)
TV Pitch - Sportsguy - (4-2 Mayhem)
Punnywood - Solly (85-81 Hodgey)
2018 Olympics Pyeongchang - AA (208-194 Dev)
2017-2018 Sports Franchise - Dev (8417-8057 Eric)
2017
Wrestling Rosters Booking - Hodgey (5-4 Leo)
Hero Draft 2017 - Lizzy (7-2 Mayhem)
Comedic Character Showdown - Al Bundy (6-4 Ralph Kramden)
Horror Character Showdown - Dracula (4-1 Hannibal Lecter)
Wrestling Draft - Lizzy (8-6 Eco)
Spaceship Crew - Mayhem (3-3-2 tiebreak Solly, Dev)
2016-2017 Sports Franchise - Dead (7093-6969 Shark)
2016
Movie Pitch 2016 - Hodgey (4-3. Sharky)
Pun TV 2016 - Hodgey (5-4, Solly)
Punnywood 2016 - Hodgey (107-98, Solly)
Wrestling Draft 2016 - Sharky (8-5 Matte)
TV Recast 2016 - Lizzy (7-4 Dead)
SNL Cast - Eco (6-3-2 over Smitty, Dead)
2016 Olympics Rio - AA (689-660 Dev)
2015
Wrestling Draft 2015 - Dead (6-4, Solly)
Survivor Series 2015 - Hodgey (5-4, Eco)
Survivor Series 2015 (Women) Solly (5-4, Eco)
2014
Olympics Pick'em - Firewoman (158-110, Dead) Medal points
2014 Movie Draft - Unknown
Wrestling Draft 2K14 Eric (4-4 Tiebreak, Hodgey)
Movie Recast 2014 Hodgey (3-2, Solly)
Heroes vs Villains Hodgey (3-2, Mayhem)
2013
All-Time Fantasy Hockey – Solly (5-2 Carlito)
Movie Pitch Draft – Fifth & Hodgey (Tie 6-6)
Sequeltology – The Dark Knight (6-4 The Empire Strikes Back)
Villan Team – Dev (25-22-19 Demko, Demko) *Ranking points
Survivor Series Draft - Carlito (9-6 Solly)
Hero Team - MayhemNX (19-16-13 Solly, Solly) *Ranking points
Hero Team vs Villan Team - MayhemNX (5-1 Dev)
Punapalooza - Hodgey(66-56 Solly) *Some unknown to anyone but Gator scoring system
Fictional Character Melee part Deux - Westley (6-5 Sergeant Hartman)
Movie Recast 2013 - Hodgey (4-2 Mayhem)
Superhero/Villain 2013 - Hodgey Villain (5-4 Hodgey Hero)
Build-A-Stable Draft - Dead (5-5 Tiebreak, Solly)
2012
All-Time Baseball Mikey (7-2 Shark)
Survivor Series Dev (5-5 Tiebreak, Dead)
Mix CD Draft 2 – Doug (6-5 Carlito)
Punnywood – Incomplete
Build-A-Band – Dead (5-2 Angle)
SuperHero/Villan Mega Draft Gator Villan (4-3 Gator Hero)
Wrestling Draft – Doug/Shark (9-7 Dead/Matte)
2011
Fictional Hero Megadraft - Sop (8-5 over Hodgey)
Wrestling Draft (Set Card) - Sop (9-8 over Dashbee)
Ho Down 2 - Angle (136 total votes)
Pun Box Live - Punker (5-4 over Hodgey)
Wrestlefest 2011 - EricOSystem (10-6 over Carlito)
Princess Bride Recast - Shark (10-8-4 Hodgey, Mayhem)
Superhero/Villan – Dev (3-3 Tiebreak Gator)
TV Draft – Doug (6-5-2 Eric, Solly)
CBM Comic Team Showdown – Incomplete
Movie Pitch Draft – Hodgey (5-3 Doug)
Superconference Draft – Incomplete
2010
Supervillain Team Draft - DevSop (10-8 over BTR)
Superhero Team Draft - Gator (5-5 over Jobber via tiebreak)
Survivor Series Draft - Dashbee (8-7 over Hodgey)
Ho Down Draft - DevSop
Punnywood Movie Studio Draft - Solly
Superconference Draft - DevSop
The Expundables Draft - Simmons (9-8 over Angle)
Mix CD Draft - Solly (6-2 over Gator)
Wrestlefest 2010 - Eco (8-5 over Dashbee)
Star Wars Recast Draft - Hodgey (7-7 over Stu via tiebreak)
PPV Supercard Draft - Mikey (5-4-1-1 over Eric, Dash, Thai)
PH Supergroup Idol 2 - Solly (4-3 over Lou)
2009
What’s for Dinner Draft - Pun (11-10 over Mikey)
Punster of the Year (POTY) - Solly (17-13 over Punker)
Punnywood Movie Studio Draft - Creepy (12-5 over Habsy)
Punnywood Movie Studio Box Office - Solly
Supergroup Idol Draft - Blitz (11-6 over Jobber)
Punapalooza Draft (Day 1) - Punker (12-2 over Court)
Punapalooza Draft (Day 2) - Hodgey (8-7 over Thai)
Punapalooza Draft (Days 1 & 2) - Punker & Hodgey (9-9 Tie)
90s Mix CD Draft - Hodgey (5-2 over BC)
Superhero Team Draft - Ziggy (8-8 over Hodgey via tiebreak)
PunTV Draft - Angstboy (10-10 over Eric via tiebreak)
Historical Figure Wrestling Alliance Draft - Incomplete
Sports Character Draft - Mikey (3-1 over DevSop)
Wrestling Draft - Eric (12-10 over Eco)
2008
Network Drama TV Showdown - LOST (9-5 over Heroes)
Tag Team Showdown - Hart Foundation (13-12 over Edge & Christian)
Hot Chicks Showdown (Sports) - Willa Ford (7-3 over Anna Benson)
Hot Chicks Showdown (Wrestling) - Mickie James (20-16 over Trish Stratus)
Stand-Up Comedian Showdown - Richard Pryor (17-14 over Mitch Hedberg)
Video Games Showdown - Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (13-8 over Super Mario World)
PunTV Draft - Solly (13-11 over BTR)
2007
Supervillain Showdown - Joker (10-4 over Dr. Doom)
Batman Artists Showdown - Neal Adams (9-4 over Jim Aparo)
Hot Chicks Showdown - Scarlett Johansson (12-10 over Jessica Biel)
Best Wrestler Showdown - Ric Flair (29-15 over Chris Jericho)
Kids’ TV Showdown - Looney Tunes (12-5 over Animaniacs)
Comedy TV Showdown - The Simpsons (12-6 over South Park)
Cable Drama TV Showdown - The Sopranos (7-5 over The Shield)
2006
Superhero Showdown - Batman (12-5 over Spider-Man)
W: Ties got 1 each since there is no Runner Up. Team drafts got .5 for each team member.
RUP: Some drafts had no Runner Up listed, while some had multiple. The multiples all got 1 since they made the finals, unless both Runners Up were the same person, then they just get 1. Confused? Good.
Obviously, the old-school showdowns weren't figured in.
OVERALL -------- W - RUP
Hodgey --------- 23 - 13
DevSop --------- 13 - 7
Solly ---------- 12 - 13
Mayhem --------- 7 - 9
Eco ------------ 5.5 - 6
Shark ---------- 5.5 - 3
Dead ----------- 4 - 5.5
Matte ---------- 4 - 3.5
Eric ----------- 3.5 - 8
Sportsguy ------ 3 - 4
Mikey ---------- 3 - 1
Punker --------- 3 - 1
Lizzy ---------- 3 - 0
Doug ----------- 2.5 - 1
Leo ------------ 2 - 7
Gator ---------- 2 - 3
Cole ----------- 2 - 1
AA ------------- 2 - 0
Cletus --------- 2 - 0
Dashbee -------- 1 - 3
Carlito -------- 1 - 3
Angle ---------- 1 - 2
Creepy --------- 1 - 0
Angstboy ------- 1 - 0
OpTard --------- 1 - 0
Pun ------------ 1 - 0
Blitz ---------- 1 - 0
Fifth Horseman - 1 - 0
Firewoman ------ 1 - 0
Dalem ---------- 1 - 0
Demko ---------- 0 - 2
BTR ------------ 0 - 2
Thai ----------- 0 - 2
Jobber --------- 0 - 2
BC ------------- 0 - 2
Habs ----------- 0 - 1
Courtney ------- 0 - 1
Lou ------------ 0 - 1
Stu ------------ 0 - 1
Smitty --------- 0 - 1