[The Canadian Content]

Solly
Luke Skywalker: Tobey Maguire
Han Solo: Josh Holloway
Princess Leia Organa: Jessica Alba
Obi-Wan Kenobi: Clint Eastwood
Lando Calrissian: Carl Weathers
Chewbacca: The Undertaker
Yoda: Hank Azaria
C-3PO: William Daniels
Uncle Owen: Jeff Bridges
Aunt Beru: Julie Kavner
Darth Vader: Morgan Freeman
Emperor Palpatine: Anthony Hopkins
Grand Moff Tarkin: Terence Stamp


Gator
Luke Skywalker: Jake Gyllenhall
Han Solo: Ryan Reynolds
Princess Leia Organa: Evangeline Lilly
Obi-Wan Kenobi: Patrick Stewart
Lando Calrissian: Thai Dao
Chewbacca: Matt Morgan
Yoda: Mel Blanc
C-3PO: Craig Ferguson
Uncle Owen: Michael Keaton
Aunt Beru: Jane Seymour
Darth Vader: Laurence Fishburne
Emperor Palpatine: Michael Emerson
Grand Moff Tarkin: Alan Rickman

[Deleted]

One of these casts has this guy:

[Stu]

The only real blemish on Gator's is Evangeline Lilly as Leia (not Thai though, because the films need more asians. I think there's actually more Maori actors in the two trilogies), while I can't see Clint as Obi-Wan at all, and Maguire and Alba are really mismatched as twins for me.

[DevSop]

Not a fan of Alba as Leia. Love Holloway as Han though. Eastwood sucks. I think Gator got a little too cute with some of his picks though so this is tough. I think Emerson and Rickman swing it to Gator for me.

[Sportsguy]

I really wish Gator had dropped Lilly, gotta go with Solly here

[creepy]

Gators Stewart/Rickman/Fishburne get beat by Sollys Eastwood/Weathers/Bridges/Villains. Solly's leads suck, but he has enough ammo to beat Gator here.

[Deadly]

I hate to vote against Holloway as Han, but I think Gator's cast is better top to bottom.

[Habs]

Thai (no offence) has no right to be in there. No way he can pull Lando.

Lando is no bass guitarist, rhythm guitar maybe.

Solly

[Deleted]

Thai was (is?) also a strip club DJ. That screams "pimp" on about 7 different levels, to me.

[Habs]

Then I cast Pun as an Ewok!

[The Jewish Cunthead]

Congrats, uh, Beefcake