[Deleted]

PICK 2!!!

Solly
Westley - James Franco
Buttercup - Mila Kunis
Inigo Montoya - Danny McBride
Fezzik - Lou Ferigno
Vizini - Jonah Hill
Prince Humperdink - Paul Rudd
Count Rugen - Will Ferrell
The Albino - Seth Rogen
The Impressive Clergyman - Jason Segel
Miracle Max - John C. Reilly
Valerie - Jane Lynch
The Grandfather - Morgan Freeman
The Grandson - Gary Coleman

Dead
Westley - Heath Ledger
Buttercup - Kari Byron
Inigo Montoya - Benicio Del Toro
Fezzik - Ving Rhames
Vizini - Michael Ironside
Prince Humperdink - Cilian Murphy
Count Rugen - Johnny Depp
The Albino - Gary Oldman
The Impressive Clergyman - Ken Jeong
Miracle Max - John Cusack
Valerie - Joan Cusack
The Grandfather - James Earl Jones
The Grandson - Bobb'e Thompson

Mayhem
Westley - Chris Hemsworth
Buttercup - Reese Witherspoon
Inigo Montoya - Antonio Banderas
Fezzik - Richard Kiel
Vizini - Danny DeVito
Prince Humperdink - Julian McMahon
Count Rugen - Tim Curry
The Albino - Nick Frost
The Impressive Clergyman - John Lithgow
Miracle Max - Paul Giamatti
Valerie - Lori Petty
The Grandfather - Michael Caine
The Grandson - Angus T. Jones

[The Canadian Content]

I think Ferigno might be the best Fezzik replacement in the whole draft.

[Road Warrior Shark]

I think we just had a Draft involving actors that Solly DIDN'T take Stallone

[The Jewish Cunthead]

I was THISCLOSE to making a Very Stallone TPB.

Burt Young as Vizzini, Dolph as Fezzik, etc.

[Sportsguy]

Solly and Mayhem. I like alot of Dead's cast, but can't stand Kari Byron and the Cusacks playing husband and wife kinda creeps me out a bit

[MayhemNX]

Honeslty had Solly not taken her I would have grabbed Mila for Valerie, I think she would have worked better in that role

[Road Warrior Shark]

Mila as Valerie? Really?

I was eyeing her for Buttercup too, but figured there were plenty of good looking gals to play that role and passed on her

[MayhemNX]

Well, the whole point of Valerie is to be this shrill, annoying, loudmouthed shrew, and she had that in spades (albeit hot spades) on 70s show

[Deleted]

Via coinflip, Incest Dead moves on!