Below is an alphabetical list of everyone we nominated. (I caught about 6 more duplicates, just subbed in characters basically everyone knows unilaterally.)
Could use another pair of eyes to see if there are any duplicates I missed; otherwise, should we do any kind of seeding or should we just get this rolling with random order? I'm thinking 16 matches a day every two days? That would make Round One take a month, so open to doing more or doing them faster. (Could be 16 a day, but polls open for two days on each.)
Abed Nadir Ace Ventura Adrian Cronauer Al Bundy Al Czervik Alex P. Keaton Andy (The 40-Year-Old Virgin) Angie Tribeca Annie Edison April Ludgate Archie Bunker Ari Gold Arnold Jackson (Diff'rent Strokes) Arthur Fonzarelli "Fonzi" of Happy Days Austin Powers Axel Foley Barney Rubble Barney Stinson Basil Fawlty of Fawlty Tours Beau Bennett Beavis Bill. S. Preston, Esquire Billy Madison Billy Ray Valentine Black Knight (Holy Grail) Bob McKenzie Bojack Horseman Borat Brennan Huff Brian Fantana Brian Griffin Brick Tamland Britta Perry Buck Laughlin from Best in Show. Buddy the Elf Buffy Summers Buford T. Justice of Smokey and the Bandit Bugs Bunny Bullwinkle Butt-head Cal (The 40-Year-Old Virgin) Calvin "Nuke" Laloosh Carl Spackler Carlton Banks Cheryl Tunt Chief Inspector Yan Naing Lee (Rush Hour) Christopher Turk (Scrubs) Clayton Bigsby Cleo McDowell Cliff Huxtable Cordelia Chase Cosmo Kramer Count Rugen Crash Davis Curly (Stooge) Dale Doback Dan Fielding Daniel Hillard/Mrs. Doubtfire Dark Helmet David (The 40-Year-Old Virgin) David St. Hubbins (Spinal Tap) Deadpool Del Griffith Dennis Reynolds Deputy Barney Fife Derek Smalls from Spinal Tap. Derek Zoolander Det. James Carter (Rush Hour) Det. Sgt. Nick Yemana Detective Billy Rosewood Dory (Finding Nemo/Dory) Doug McKenzie Dr. Benjamin Franklin "Hawkeye" Pierce Dr. Evil Dr. Frederick Frankenstein Dr. Johnny Fever Dr. Kreiger Dr. Perry Cox Dr. Peter Venkman Dr. Rumack Dudley "Booger" Dawson Dusty Bottoms Ed Hocken Ed Norton ( Honeymooners) Edith Bunker Elaine Benes Elwood Blues Eric Cartman Ernie "Coach" Pantusso Eunice Harper Higgins Farva of Super Troopers Ferris Bueller Fezzik Fire Marshall Bill Fletch Fozzie Bear Frank Drebin Frank the Tank Frasier Crane Fred Sanford Freddy Benson French Knight (Holy Grail) Garth Algar Genie (Aladdin) George Costanza George Jefferson Geraldine Jones Gilligan of Gilligan's Island Gina Linetti Granny of the Beverly Hillbillies H.I. McDunnough of Raising Arizona Hank Hill Hank Scorpio Happy Gilmore Harry Doyle Headley Lamar of Blazing Saddles Herbert (Family Guy) Homer Simpson Homey D Clown Huey Freeman Hyacinth Bucket Inspector Clouseau (Sellers) Jack Burton of Big Trouble in Little China Jack Tripper of Three's Company Jackie Burkhart Jake Blues Jake Peralta Jay (Jay & Silent Bob) Jeff Spicoli Jeff Winger Jefferson Davis Hogg JJ Evans Joey Tribbiani John "Bluto" Blutarsky John Bender Johnathan Moxon Johnny Henshaw-Jacobs (Airplane!) Judge Smails Juno MacGuff Karen Walker Kelly Bundy Kelly Kapowski Kenny Powers Kermit the Frog Kevin McCalliste Kimmy Schmidt King Jaffe Joffer Kirk Lazarus Kitty Forman Knives Chau Lana Kane Larry (Stooge) Leon Black Les Grossman Leslie Knope Lily Aldrin Lisa Simpson Lone Star Lorelai Gilmore Lou Brown Lucille Bluth Lucky Day Lucy Ricardo Luther Van Dam of Coach. Machete Marshall Eriksen Marvin the Martian Matt Foley (SNL) Maude Maxwell Klinger Maxwell Smart of Get Smart McLovin Michael Kelso Michael Scott Mike Baxter Mike Flaherty (Spin City) Mike Seaver Miracle Max Miss Piggy Moe (Stooge) Mooj (The 40-Year-Old Virgin) Motherfucker Jones Mr. Robinson (SNL) Navin Johnson Neal Page Ned Flanders Ned Nederlander Nell Naugatuck (housekeeper on Maude. Look her up) Nigel Tufnel (Spinal Tap) Norm Peterson Pam Poovey Patsy Stone Pee Wee Herman Phil Dunphy Phoebe Buffay President Scroob Prince Akeem Ralph Cramden Randal Graves Ray Holt Red Forman Reggie Hammond Regina George Rev. Jim Ignatowski Rick Vaughn Ricky Bobby Rob Petrie of The Dick Van Dyke Show Robin Scherbatsky Ron Burgundy Ron Swanson Roseanne Connor Rowlf Rufus T. Firefly Sally Solomon Sam Malone Scooby-Doo Sean Connery (SNL) Selina Meyer Sgt. Nick Angel (Hot Fuzz) Shaun (of the Dead) Sideshow Bob Silent Bob Silky Johnson (Chappelle's Show) Smokey (Friday) Sophia Petrillo Spongebob Squarepants Stefon (SNL) Sterling Archer Steve Stiffler Sue Heck Ted Theodore Logan Terry Jeffords The Church Lady The Dude The Girl You Wish You Hadn't Started a Conversation With at a Party The Roadrunner The Swedish Chef The Tramp (Charlie Chaplin) Thornton Melon Tim the Enchanter Tobias Funke Tom Haverford Tommy Callahan Troy Barnes Ty Webb Uncle Buck Russell Veronica Corningstone Vizzini Walter Sobchak Wayne Campbell Wile E. Coyote Will Smith (Fresh Prince of Bel Air) Willie Mays Hayes Willy Wonka of Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory. Winnie Cooper Woody Boyd