[Lucky]

Alyssa Milano




vs

Alyson Hannigan

[Lucky]

I really think this one should be a rout. And its not that I don't think Hannigan's hot, but she ain't in Milano's league. I posted that half naked pic because people seem to like it but that skinny nothing body with no ass, no chest, no legs, no tone, and the short hair always took him from hot to not in my book. Meanwhile I made a point to grab that shot of the older her because I think she really developed into a beautiful woman. She filled out a bit, and not just in the breasts but really all over including her face. A good thing, I say. She's cute and incredibly fuckable. And seems like she's got a bit of a wild streak, which any redhead should. And I mean, she's a redhead and there's a sad shortage of redheads in this tourney.

But she ain't in the league of Milano, who basically went from teen hottie to mature babe to the older hot chick she is today. I didn't even pull out great pics for her because I hope she'll last another round and I'm saving the big guns. But I don't want to outright dismiss Willow. I never much cared for her back then but she really has matured into a woman who'd I'd go right for (and one that makes me think she'd entertain me despite being well out of my league). Despite having that network show she seems to have taken a pretty low profile, but whenever I see her I'm reminded of that.

But she's up against a goddess. Who loves baseball.

[Loki]

I get your argument. And I might have voted for Milano. But there was something about her n the middle / later eps of Charmed that turned me off. Maybe it was the combo of short hair / tats / crappy outfits / annoying character. Dunno. And it's not that short hair and tats are a turnoff, per se, but all those together on ep after ep acted like a cold shower.

Besides, there's something about Hanningan nowadays. Definitely tagable. She got my vote.

[Lucky]

So am I right in presuming that most of the Pro-Hannigan/Anti-Milano crowd is coming from the vantage point of Avid Buffy AND Charmed viewers? Huh.

I had even forgotten that both women played witches for extended periods of time to make that witty tie.

[Batman]

Not me, man. Never watched Buffy. But I've found Hannigan hot ever since American Pie.

I never watched Charmed either, but I would definitely say that I find Milano least-hot of the witches.

[Batman]

Also: What "crowd"? There appear to be three of us thus far.

[docx]

I think Allyson Hannigan was the second hottest chick in American Pie. SHe was definitely hot in Buffy, too. Cute, but you want to put it in her, too.

That said, who here hasn't wanted to tag Alyssa Milano since they were, like, 12 years old? I can say that she's one of the first TV snicketies to make the young doc's dreams. You're talking 18 or 19 years of quality hotness. I gotta go with the lifetime achievement award and vote for Ms. Milano.

[Lucky]

sergeial said:

Also: What "crowd"? There appear to be three of us thus far.

I don't know. I came into this showdown scared of an upset a bit. I even came into this thread right now looking to make a case for her before I realized she's not in big danger. I'm very protective.

Alyssa Milano has a baseball blog.
alyssa.mlblogs.com/alyssa/

Or maybe some weird internet person as too much time on their hands and is pretending she has a blog. But for now I'll choose to believe it and say just how much I love her.

[williamssl]

Alyssa said:

It’s about knowing how your home field grass is cut.

JEOMK




EDIT: that quote is from the blog Lucky referenced.

[DevSop]

I think I'm part of the Buffy/Charmed block that Lucky was mentioning and I really was considering Hannigan because there are times when I find her adorable and times when I find Milano a flat-out tramp. But a couple of things convinced me; Milano's peak is so far above and beyond Hannigan's that if Milano didn't have the negatives I think she has I could easily see her winning the whole thing. And secondly, Milano's negatives are not that far below Hannigan's negatives. The dorky, pale Willow is a huge negative from early seasons of Buffy. And she was never one of my fave characters where I can use that as a reason to vote for her. So my vote has changed from my original thought. Go Milano.

[Lucky]

Yeah, I think Dev is now the 2nd guy I thought might be voting Hannigan that had me scared. I was sort of keeping a running tab in my head and I was worried that I was counting quite a few votes for her. But it doesn't look like they're actually going that way.

[DevSop]

But this vote also means Gellar is def. getting my vote in her first round matchup as I have to give the Buffy girls as much love as I can. Eliza, Charisma, and Sarah all need votes.

[Jack Quinn]

meh Alyssa had her moment, I voted for Alyson. I mean didn't Alyssa date a Yankee and/or Met? ewwwww

[Mikey]

I think I voted for Alyson last night. I couldn't stand her in American Pie and all that, but she's grown up now and totally hot. Reminds me of a girl I used to have a thing for in high school.

But if Milano wins, that's cool, too.

[Lucky]

mooseheadjack said:

meh Alyssa had her moment, I voted for Alyson. I mean didn't Alyssa date a Yankee and/or Met? ewwwww

Nah. She did Pavano pre-Yankees. Zito, Penny, and Beckett too (I think). Lady loves her pitchers. Yet another reason I love her.

[Chris Eco]

devilsoprano said:

The dorky, pale Willow is a huge negative from early seasons of Buffy.

I like dorky pale girls. I DATE dorky pale girls. I vote Hannigan.

Jerk.

[The Canadian Content]

Milano.

[Batman]

ecosystem said:

I like dorky pale girls. I DATE dorky pale girls.

So I presume you'll be joining Solly and me in trying to overcome the general apathy about the awesomeness of Thora Birch?



Pale? Check. Dorky? Super-check!

[Loki]

ecosystem said:

devilsoprano said:

The dorky, pale Willow is a huge negative from early seasons of Buffy.

I like dorky pale girls. I DATE dorky pale girls. I vote Hannigan.

Jerk.

Dork? Check.

Pale? Check.

I found Eco's next date!

[Loki]

Eco! MSNBC just flashed that Rosie is leaving The View! She's gonna need some comfortin' tonight - better head on down.

[Batman]

She's not wearing glasses.

[docx]

loki said:

better head on down.

...if you know what I mean.

Hey, quick request. Can we keep the wang-shriveling bulldyke hoooors off the wang-plumping hot chick tourney pages, please.
That's like unwrapping your yummy Hershey's Special Dark (tm) candy bar, and discovering that you've gotten a Hershey's Maggot-Encrusted Dogturd (tm) bar instead.

NO MORE ROSEY!! EVAR!!!

[williamssl]

While I can do censored words, I can't set up any sort of admin-driven function to automatically replace fat sloppy lesbobitch pictures with pics of goodness.

This one's gonna have to be left to the residents.

[Evil Scotty]

loki said:

ecosystem said:

I like dorky pale girls. I DATE dorky pale girls. I vote Hannigan.

Jerk.

Dork? Check.

Pale? Check.

I found Eco's next date!

He actually had her on his list.

[Lucky]

Fans of dorky pale girls, you have 2 days left to try and defeat the goddess. Willow's going to need quite a push by midnight EST, Sunday night.