[Chris Eco]

(1) Batman and Robin



vs.

(6) Cat in the Hat



Polling closes....heck, let's say Saturday noon. Give everyone a chance to get in.

Anyone care to convince me which way to vote?

[williamssl]

IMDB Ratings:
Batman & Robin: 3.5/10
Cat in the Hat: 3.2/10
Cat wins.

Rotten Tomatoes Ratings:
Batman & Robin: 12%
Cat in the Hat: 12%
Tie

Cat sucks more than Batman (and DevSop) in at least one major online movie community. Therefore Cat wins.


Now if Cat in the Hat were like this YouTube clip, it might have been a good movie and a top seed in our Horror showdown. Alas....

[Krydor]

nipples on a batsuit

[Lori]

I'll vote in the case of a tie. But someone should message me, because I probably won't check.

[williamssl]

I am anxious to see Krydor's reaction when the Raiders new uniform features nipples.

[williamssl]

Also for Krydor (and a bump to this poll - anyone else gonna vote here?)

[Jack Quinn]

I don't know, fake nipples on a bat suit and all, it was a bad movie, but did it vary so far from the "spirit" of batman to make it an insult to the series? (I really don't know, I have never seen it, Batman and super hero movies in general bore the hell out of me).

But Cat in the Hat, man, that took something that was fun for kids (and adults I suppose) and made it into something mean spirited, nasty and obnoxious.

Batman will survive, Dr. Seuss should kick the shit out of whoever wrote that movie.

[Courtney]

I tied it because...well, I thought it'd be fun.

[Lori]

Tex helped me out with 28 Days Later, and although Batman & Robin was certainly the worst Batman movie, I never really believed that it belonged in this showdown anyway. I hate to be the decision on a movie I've never seen, but I guess Cat wins, unless there's anyone left to tie it up again.

[Krydor]

williamssl said:

I am anxious to see Krydor's reaction when the Raiders new uniform features nipples.

??????????? Wat???????

Cowboys are teh SUK

[williamssl]

ecosystem said:

Polling closes....heck, let's say Saturday noon. Give everyone a chance to get in.

YAY!!! We Win!

[National Champion Chris Cole]

Proving that you don't actually have to be the worst movie only have the best campaign manager behind you. Congrats to Tex for pulling six seed to victory. Is this the lowest seed to win any of our showdowns?

[williamssl]

In fairness, Cat in the Hat was really fucking bad and there were several others voting in this who felt similarly. And I'm convinced that if Mike Myers catsuit had nipples on it, there would have been a lot more swing votes in this particular matchup.

[salmonjunkie]

While I haven't seen Cat in the Hat I can't argue it being worse than Batman & Robin. Because at least from Batman & Robin, you were able to get this awesome clip:

Cool!