[Lucky]

Keira Knightley





vs


Erica Durance




Poll closes Sunday.

[The Canadian Content]

Erica who?

[Lucky]

Don't ask me. I watch her show and I can't believe she's winning.

[DevSop]

This is making me so happy. Voting for someone who looks like a human being compared to Knightley who on her good days is amazing, but on her bad days is thinner than Kate Moss and should have bags of donuts shoved down her throat.

[Lucky]

I agree that Knightley has some scary bad days, but Durance's best days don't come close to Knightley's. And really, we don't have any impressionable young ladies here. So I'm picking and choosing which pictures I'm looking at. If Knightley was going against an equally hot woman I'd probably count those bad days against her. But Durance? I mean, Marilyn Monroe has been having quite a few bad days lately but she advanced on her prime.

[DevSop]

Durance has never made me want to vomit. Knightley has. And yes I will admit Keira's best days are better than Erica's, but Erica doesn't have bad days from everything I've seen her in. And plus she went on Howard years ago and called herself a nympho.

[Mikey]

I knows me some fine skinny women. Keira is nice, but she's not all that. With a tougher draw, I woulda had her out in the first round.

[Lucky]

Trust me, you don't have to convince me on the bad Keira pics. Some of those skinny ones are really fucking horrible. Granted, I think she walks a fine line. Because in one pic she'll be skinny but have a 6 pack and in the next she'll just be skinny. So there has to be some level of optical illusion or "I didn't work out the last few weeks" happening there.

I think 75% of the time when I see Durance on Smallville I have absolutely no sexual desire for her. There's that other 25% where she does something different and I like, but Durance is really one of the least attractive hot women I can think of around pop culture at the moment. That being said, I'm not going to pretend I've seen pictures of her that compare to some of those horrid paparazzi pics of Knightley.

But really, it comes down to the fact that Keira has a much larger volume of hotness then Durance does (IMO). And the very real anti-hotness Keira occasionally slips into is not nearly enough to even that up. Seeing as how we've had women in this tourney who are 20 years past their primes, 40 years in the grave, and completely horrible messes how come Knightley gets judged on a smattering of bad days at the beach?

Bastards.

[Chris Eco]

Well, I'm putting Keira back in it. Someone give her a lead.

[BC]

If anyone has seen Bend It Like Beckham, you get to see Knightley at her skeletal best. It was pretty gross & everytime I see her I flash back to that & cringe

[Lucky]

Sorry. We don't watch soccer movies made for little girls starring 16 year old girls.

But you go ahead and keep leering at that 16 year old body.

[DevSop]

This voting makes me so happy. Fuck Knightley, It's about time we took a step to helping to prove anorexia is not hot.

[Lucky]

I just watched the latest episode of Smallville which but Durance in a major role and I once again must look at this poll and ask "REALLY?!" Durance unbelievably has a 9-7 lead. 24 hours if anyone wants to set things right.

[Lucky]

And we have our 1st fallen 1 seed! And of all people its the mini-tourney co-winner Keira Knightley! I must say, I understand all the arguments against Knightley and in no way am shocked to see her go down early. I am shocked to see her go down to Erica Durance. Erica now moves onto the sweet 16 to more than likely get destroyed because half the voters have no clue who she is. 9-8 Durance.

[National Champion Chris Cole]

Damn it. I hate being late. I'd have tied this up.