[Courtney]

Here we go again. After dismissing one of my faves American Beauty ( ), 8th seed Field of Dreams comes up against powerhouse #1 seed Shawshank Redemption. Can Kevin and his little field take down Andy and Red? Let us see.


The Shawshank Redemption



vs.

Field of Dreams



Polls Close Wednesday at 8 PST

Repeat for Psycho: Wednesday at 8! ;D

[Mikey]

Only thing worse than this draw for me would be to put Field of Dreams against Rocky.

That being said, if I could only watch one of these movies the rest of my life, it's Field of Dreams.

[Jack Quinn]

I went with Shawshank

Though Field of Dreams is a damn fine movie

[The Jewish Cunthead]

AND IT'S FATASS BY A NOSE!

[Batman]

I'm so happy that at least one of these two sap-fests is going away. I'm voting Field, simply because I plan to vote against Shawshank every time.

[The Jewish Cunthead]

Shawshank is a sapfest? A man was in prison for almost 20 years for a crime he didn't do. A sharp cry from mowing your corn, putting up a baseball field and driving cross-country with James Earl Jones.

[Krydor]

Field of Dreams, dudes.

[Lucky]

What's with Sir Gay whining about sap fests? For all his "if you have daddy issues you'll love Empire" crap? And his Romeo+Juliet fandom?

[creepy]

R+J was one of the only movies I've walked out on.

As far as this one, I love both movies, so I'll go with FoD.

[Batman]

Hey, I'm not saying I don't like emotional movies. I just can't think of a better way to say "I don't like movies that make Tarheel cry."

[Chris Eco]

Field of Dreams. Stupid daddy issues.

[Lori]

No contest. This is my favorite King short story, and by far the best King movie.

[Mikey]

sergeial said:

Hey, I'm not saying I don't like emotional movies. I just can't think of a better way to say "I don't like movies that make Tarheel cry."

It was probably a bad idea to vote this matchup then.

[Batman]

I didn't think of it as a vote for Field of Dreams, I thought of it as a vote against Shawshank.

[docx]

Kevin Costner didn't endure assrape.
Kevin Costner didn't get locked in the hole for a month.
Kevin Costner didn't pull a grub out of his oatmeal.
Kevin Costner didn't crawl through poop.

Shawshank by a mile.

[salmonjunkie]

Kevin Costner didn't use pinup girls to hide his master plan of digging a tunnel out of his cell with a spoon for over 20 years.

[Courtney]

What the hell? How is this tied? Who voted last?

EDIT: God Jebus, Psycho. Argh.

[Brother X]

Both movies are awesome.
I still say that the America monologue from FoD is one of Teh Best Evar!

But SR is too good to not make it at least to the finals. If you jackholes are going to make a travesty out this thing in the first place with that insane GFII debacle, at least redeem yourselves by moving Red & Co. through to the end.