[Courtney]

Wow, I don't know how I'm gonna choose between these two. Vote 4 Sale.

The Shawshank Redemption



v.

Pulp Fiction[/b]



Polls close Saturday at 8 PST!

[The Canadian Content]

PF for me.

[The Jewish Cunthead]

I'm running around like Penfold. "Oh crikey, oh crumbs!"

I can't decide.

FUCK.

[Batman]

EXALT!

(For the DM ref.)

[Krydor]

Shawshank.

[Jack Quinn]

I'll take Shawshank, but this one is close

[The Jewish Cunthead]

If Rocky is my #1, Shawshank is 2A and Pulp is 2B. I really can't decide yet.

[dsolo1986]

I think Pulp had a bigger impact and is a lot more original than Shawshank.

[Lori]

Wasn't even a question for me. Shawshank.

[creepy]

fsolomon75 said:

If Rocky is my #1, Shawshank is 2A and Pulp is 2B. I really can't decide yet.

Easy, Solly, 2A>2B.

As for me, I don't even care. SR = PF for my enjoyability.

[docx]

Shawshank wins on the strength of Red alone. His monologue to the parole board at the end is movie magic. He is not an innocent man. He is a man who did a really terrible thing and actually learned from it. That scene is tops among some pretty fucking awesome scenes.

[salmonjunkie]

two of my very favorite movies of all time...

Too bad for Shawshank that Pulp Fiction IS my favorite movie of all time. Courtney, I will buy your vote. Vote Pulp Fiction.

Only rule - you can't make me vote against Lord of The Rings movies or Monty Python and the Holy Grail

[Lori]

No Courtney, don't do it! If you haven't already, for the love of god, do not vote against Shawshank! Best. King. Movie. Ever.

[The Jewish Cunthead]

Yeah, it's right up there with Cat's Eye.

[Stu]

I love both, and I'm watching Pulp right now. ARRGGGH.

uk.youtube.com/watch?v=KtwXlIwozog

uk.youtube.com/watch?v=RKuDYbnXBJQ

[The Jewish Cunthead]

The best part about that scene doesn't even involve Walken. It's that horrific cartoon Butch is watching with the character superimposed over some dude's face.

"He think totem pole alive."

That shit has always cracked me up and I must have seen that flick literally at least 100 times.

[Courtney]

I think I just might abstain unless my vote's absolutely needed. It's just now Wednesday so there's a couple more days.

[Mikey]

One of these movies is really good.

And then one of these movies is one of the three greatest movies ever.

I'm disappointed in 8 of you.

[creepy]

courtney said:

I think I just might abstain unless my vote's absolutely needed. It's just now Wednesday so there's a couple more days.

My thoughts exactly. You vote for one, I'll vote for the other.

[The Jewish Cunthead]

I hope Shawshank wins...

Hope is a good thing

[Courtney]

Alright, since Solly decided to jump the gun a bit ;D, I already closed the AHX v. Empire poll. I'm gonna leave this one open until tomorrow just in case Thai can pull in more votes for his fave.

[salmonjunkie]

VOTE PULP FICTION! IT'S THE BEST!


That about as much as I can do.

[creepy]

Screw it. I'll pull Pulp Fiction within one.

[Jack Quinn]

What I wonder about the two is this:

To me, Shawshank is a good movie because it is a good story that is told well.

Pulp Fiction is a good movie because it is an ok story, that is told in a way we hadn't seen before.

I think Pulp Fiction is a movie that will be remembered for it's uniqueness, and spawning a whole genre of movies (and if I am wrong on that, feel free to correct me, I know after PF there were a bunch of Tarantino-seque movies, but I am not sure that PF was necessarily the first of its kind)

I think Shawshank will be remembered because it is a great story that is told well by some remarkable actors.

Shawshank got my vote in this one

[Courtney]

Alright, closing this one. SR wins and Thai's heart breaks.