[Courtney]

You've got my favorite Robin Williams movie vs. my dad's favorite baseball movie. My vote's going to GWH not only because I love it, but for another reason: Ben Affleck is the worst actor I've ever seen. He's in this movie and it doesn't bother me. I actually kinda like him in this movie. That is amazing!


Good Will Hunting



vs.

The Natural

[The Jewish Cunthead]

FUUUUUUUCK!

I could cry that I have to vote between these two.

[Brother X]

GWH is great, no question.

But the Natural is beautiful from start to finish. Every frame fits. Even Glenn Close looks good in it.

[salmonjunkie]

I loved GWH. Never seen The Natural.

[Lucky]

I'm Mr. Baseball and all but the Natural never really moved me. Then again, Good Will Hunting didn't either. It was a good film, but didn't get me. I should rewatch it.

They Hollywoodized the ending drastically and completely changed it from the book. That never sits too well with me. Then again, GWH just felt like a good movie like you'd make if someone gave you a blueprint and you followed it to a tee. No real spark in it, just completely well done across the board to complete your task perfectly. I have that feeling about pretty much every Van Zant movie I've seen though. And oddly, most Damon films (the good ones). They inspire no passion in me, they're just good in an almost pedestrian way. Affleck chewing out Damon is the only scene I feel to really feel anything for and I'm not sure I do.

[creepy]

salmonjunkie said:

I loved GWH. Never seen The Natural.

Same.

[The Canadian Content]

I'm going with GWH too. Loved The Natural, but not as much as GWH.

[docx]

Good Will Hunting is one of my all time favorites. One of the (VERY) few movies that makes me cry.
(Unlike Tarheel Mike)