[Courtney]

Why is it the Brad Pitt movies that I plead for? Please, for the love of all things holy and Edward Norton, vote for Fight Club!


Fight Club



vs.

Glory

[The Jewish Cunthead]

Why Glory should win: it made Broderick believable in a dramatic role... and oh yeah, it had Denzel, Freeman and Andre Braugher, not to mention it was a true story. I mean if we're talking drama, I'll take my chances with an all-black regiment fighting in the Civil War vs. Norton and Pitt stealing human fat.

Why it won't: you're all racists

[Mikey]

fsolomon75 said:

Why it won't: you're all racists

Keep everybody weak!

[creepy]

Fight Club had a great first half. Glory had a great first half and a great second half.

I work with a dude whose middle name is Robert and his last name is Paulson. True story.

[salmonjunkie]

I've never seen Glory. I liked Fight Club (shit, I even have it on DVD), but I don't love it (I probably have it because it was one of the first DVDs I bought). So... I don't know if I should vote for Fight Club...

[creepy]

When I got my first DVD player, Fight Club was the first DVD that I bought. But I don't love it, either.

[National Champion Chris Cole]

I still have trouble following Fight Club.

[docx]

Fight Club is fantastic. Stayed fairly true to the book, and uglied up that pretty boy Brad Pitt some. Gotta vote for that.

[Batman]

I don't know. I loved Fight Club up until the end. But the big plan was to take out all the credit-card debt? WTF? Yeah, that's going to make the whole world a better place, suuure. . . .

[dsolo1986]

Hands down Glory. When Denzel lifts the flag at the end, I still get shivers on the back of my neck...and I've seen the movie at least 25 times.

[Lucky]

sergeial said:

I don't know. I loved Fight Club up until the end. But the big plan was to take out all the credit-card debt? WTF? Yeah, that's going to make the whole world a better place, suuure. . . .

All I could figure when I saw that was "well I don't have credit card debt. What the fuck difference does it make to me?" Strangely I still don't have credit card debt and my life still would have gone unchanged. Of course I'm sometimes some squatting and soap making away from living a little too close to Tyler Durdan.

C'mon! Glory! You kids have no respect for the great ones!

[Krydor]

Love Glory. Love Fight Club. Denzel is the man, therefore Glory wins.

[The Jewish Cunthead]

The prayer speech before the final battle in Glory

The final battle

[Courtney]

Shit. Punker's gonna get tired of hearing from me.

[The Canadian Content]

Wait! I didn't vote yet!




Kidding...

[Courtney]

I actually checked to see if you had. ;D

[The Canadian Content]

Well then, in a very small way, I win.

[punk/core]

Chuck Palahniuk wrote Fight Club.

? wrote Glory.

So there you go.

[Mikey]

GLORY, PEOPLE!!!

[williamssl]

Wasn't punker the tiebreaker? And if so, doesn't him lobbying for one movie over another AND voting already kind of defeat the purpose? Or was there a different tiebreaker?

[punk/core]

I didn't lobby. I just gave the reason for why I voted for what.

[williamssl]

Was that the tiebreaker vote/poll's closed then? I'll lock the poll if it was.

[punk/core]

All I know is that I got a message saying the poll was tied, and my vote was needed to break said tie.

Also, maybe if Glory had been about a hole cut into the side of a bathroom stall, it might have gotten my vote.

[williamssl]

Poll's locked then. Courtney can declare the winner or re-open stuff if she had different intentions.

And sorry, Punker. I saw the poll still open (meaning people could still vote after you did) and no "Punker casts the deciding tiebreaker vote" text to indicate that was what was going on.

[Courtney]

Yeah, Punker's the tiebreaker since he hasn't voted at all in any other match-up.