[Lucky]

The third and most comedy based of the Evil Dead films sees Ash lock up against the creepy kid who sees dead people. So are you in it for the scares or the laughs?


(14) The Sixth Sense





vs



(19) Army of Darkness




Poll closes Wed at 8 PM EST.

[Lori]

I once called Army of Darkness "diarrhea of the mind," but I'm pretty sure I didn't mean it. Either that or I just like that sort of thing.

[National Champion Chris Cole]

Neither of these movies strikes me as great Horror movies. I saw all the Evil Dead Movies on a friend's recommendation and thought they were all really cheesy. They were so bad they were kind of funny. But still not very good movies.

[The Jewish Cunthead]

Ash is a fucking God.

Hail to the king, baby.

[Stu]

Army of Darkness, even though it is more of a fantasy action-adventure movie.

[Krydor]

Bruce Campbell always wins against not Bruce Campbell.

[National Champion Chris Cole]

If any of the movies made this showdown it should have been Evil Dead.

[Lucky]

I too am the rare gut who ranks his movies ED > ED2 > Army. I remember when Army came out and it was like the biggest fucking thing with my crowd. I hadn't seen the Evil Dead films, didn't really know what the big deal was about, and wasn't a horror fan yet. And Army was just kinda fun, not great. Ash is tremendous and Bruce Campbell is a god. But I dunno. Raimi and Campbell are fucking nuts and I preferred it more when they were doing horror instead of just campy comedies loosely set in horror.

Then again Sixth Sense didn't age well for me at all.

[salmonjunkie]

AoD isn't horror to me, but it's fucking awesome. I'm voting for it.

I loved Sixth Sense the first time I saw it. Liked it a lot less the next couple viewings. It's good, but it ain't Ash and his boomstick.