[DevSop]

It's the bumbling Peter Falk as out #24 Columbo in a show that's been done better against the BEST, without question, BEST sports television drama ever. It also may be the most well-acted cast from the top to the bottom of the show in #41 Friday Night Lights.


#24. COLUMBO




vs.


#41. FRIDAY NIGHT LIGHTS

[DevSop]

This is already 3 votes too many for Columbo. Again, not anything against Columbo, but Friday Night Lights is fan fucking tastic. Brilliant cast, brilliant storylines, brilliant sports scenes. I really thought I wouldn't give the show a chance because I so disliked the movie. Thought it was just a boring, boring movie...but it works so much better as a show.

Worst case scenariom look at the above pic and realize there's 3 true hotties-including the mother, and 1 soon to be hottie in the currently underage daughter.

[Pun]

devilsoprano said:

....and 1 soon to be hottie in the currently underage daughter.

For someone who's trying to shed the "dirty old man" tag, you aren't doing yourself any favors.

[Jack Quinn]

I like how Sop is being so neutral in his show descriptions

[Lucky]

I was very neutral with mine. Especially Scream.

Never seen FNL but kinda meaning to. I have seen Columbo and I have never enjoyed it at all. So I think FNL is getting this one on Hot Chick factor just judging from that cast photo. But then again I'm disturbed that one of those girls is apparently a Jail Bait Dev Special. I'm just going to hope its that youngish one mostly hidden by other people who I didn't lust for because I can't see her. And because she looks 15.

[Stu]

Columbo deserves a lot of credit though for being such an unconventional cop show (albeit one that more or less uses the same formula over and over again).

[DevSop]

It is, and actually I was wrong, she's a nice nuble, LEGAL 18 year old. So fuck all of ya.

And who said I had to be neutral? You want to run this Moose? It took me like 3 hours to get all the pictures, webpages, and set up all the threads and that was only for half the first round.

I have shows I want to win, and I'm not going to deny that. And this was one of my more neutral ones...have you checked out the Boston Public showdown?

[Jack Quinn]

I guess I just assumed you would save your lunatic rantings for when the voting wasn't going in your favor. But you beat us all to the punch!

Seriously, if you know this is just going to piss you off in the end, why did you do it in the first place?

[Lucky]

We all do that, Moose. Find me one showdown runner who was unbiased and didn't put arguments in his introductions.

[The Jewish Cunthead]

Besides, isn't it more fun when the runner gets pissed off when he or she hates the winner? (see Best Movie Drama Showdown)

[National Champion Chris Cole]

Well I don't think I put anything into the first post of the thread. I kept it neutral. But I made sure that I posted early in most threads to express my opinion.

[creepy]

I'd quote Luckys first post but then he gets all preverted and creepy. So I guess I'll:

Never seen FNL but kinda meaning to. I have seen Columbo and I have never enjoyed it at all.

[DevSop]

Closing these polls either late tonight or early tomorrow, make sure you vote if you need to.

[DevSop]

This one pains me a little as I really do think FNL is one of the best shows on television and I don't care it's only been a little over a season. And it's not meant as a negative to Columbo, but anyway Columbo moves onto round 2.