[DevSop]

An ensemble of Heroes or THE Superhero, Superman before he was super. Will you decide on longevity, quality, hot chick, or just complain? I vote most people just complain.


3)Heroes


vs.



10)Smallville

[The Jewish Cunthead]

I'm voting for the show Milo's on cuz of this:

[Lucky]

For some reason I rewatched Cursed the other week. I dunno. I'm a glutton for punishment. I mean, a Wes Craven horror from the dude who did Scream starring Christina Ricci with cameos from Shannon Elizabeth, Portia Di Rossi, and Mya can't be all bad? Right? RIGHT!?!

So I was amused when I realized just how many names are in that fucking piece of crap including names that weren't names at the time. Like Milo is the bully. Of course casting Peter Petrelli as a bully could be used as an indictment but then again he was a closeted homosexual so you figure 6 of one, half a dozen of the other. And who else is in the film? Lex Luthor! Hey! So I'm not amused to find the stars of both of these shows in that utter piece of shit. Does it mean anything? Nope. Does it

Smallville pisses me off a lot more than it scratches my geek button. Welling is a fucking horrid actor and I've never wanted Superman to be sacked punch with a kryptonite glove then I do after watching an hour of his whining ass. And fucking Kreuk/Lana. God I wish someone would murder Superman's girlfriend, hopefully graphically. And beyond that its a lot of teen angst and shitty stories and bad acting and cliched crap and derivative shit and shit crap shit turd crap poop. There's plenty of good but no getting past that bad.

Heroes' bad has never been near Smallville's and Smallville's good has never been near Heroes'. I don't agree with Moose's whining about any show he can't be bothered to watch automatically sucking but there's no fucking way that anyone above the age of 13 or who has kissed a girl should think Smallville is one of the top 4 shows of all time. No way. Nuh uh. Heroes has a case at least.

[creepy]

Shiity Superhero show beats Super Shitty Superhero show.


Sounds like a case to me!*






























*A case of jock itch.

[Courtney]

I still can't believe fucking Heroes beat ER. And I love Heroes. A Lost v. ER finale would have been pretty sweet, but this sucks. Lost all the way for me I guess.

[National Champion Chris Cole]

Tough choice. I've seen neither regularly. I've seen an episode or two of Smallville. Eventually I want to watch both. I think I'll vote Smallville because I've actually seen a few eps.

[The Jewish Cunthead]

courtney said:

A Lost v. ER finale would have been pretty sweet

Would you still vote for Lost in that matchup?

[Courtney]

I don't know. Probably, but I'd really have to think about it.

[The Jewish Cunthead]

I'd have to think really hard about it. When it was good, ER was a staple for me like RAW. I never missed an episode. As for Lost, even with a subpar 2nd season it was still better than anything else on network TV. So do two great seasons and one subpar of Lost trump 7 great and 7 average seasons of ER? I don't know.

At least this makes my decision a lot easier. No Homicide, no ER, no Blue? Lost it is.

[bigdonantonio]

Heroes I guess

[DevSop]

Come on people. 10 votes is pathetic. Wanted to close em today, but I'm not running a showdown for 10 people.