[The Jewish Cunthead]

I love both shows so this is definitely a toss-up. Too bad this is a first round matchup.

(24) I Love Lucy


vs.

(41) The Wonder Years


Voting ends 10/24

[Mikey]

Lucy will get the shaft here due to generational gaps. But I don't give a fuck, I voted for Jason Hervey.

[salmonjunkie]

Lucy will get the shaft here because Wonder Years is one of the best comedies of all time. So was Lucy, but Wonder Years is even better.

[Krydor]

So, I guess I should have paid attention to this showdown. At some point, I hope to see Simpsons and Honeymooners. Good christ... Wonder Years? Nothing better than idealized 60's crap to placate aging baby boomers.

[Jack Quinn]

I liked the Wonder Years and all, but holy hell, you are voting it over I Love Lucy? What the hell?

I remember really liking Wonder Years, but I don't recall it ever making me really laugh, certainly not like some of the Lucy episodes

[Loki]

Where's naked pictures of Winnie? Come on, Lucky!