[Lucky]

Four women tied for 2 final spots and they have to fight it out. In this first matchup we see current WWE Diva Jillian Hall try to take her very large assets and very poor singing voice into the tournament. Her opponent is porn queen turned ECW and XPW manager and the unlikely arm candy of the Blue Meanie, Jasmine St Claire.

Winner has the honor of facing Mickie James in the 1st Round.

Jillian Hall



vs

Jasmine St Claire



Feel free to post your own non-nude arguments (or links to NSFW stuff). As you may imagine, one of these women has nudes somewhere. I will not post them as we have our rules, but you know how to use google.

Bracket will automatically close Monday at midnight EST.

[Lucky]

Please note that with the board upgrade comes a new feature and you may now retract a vote. So if someone makes a convincing argument after you've voted, you can change your mind.

[DevSop]

Testing that out for ya lucky.

eta: It works.

[Stu]

My only experience of JSC in wrestling was seeing a behind the scenes piece on her being in XPW. She seems (and admits to being) a bit of a moody bitch. Plus some of the footage of her in the ring also contained Nicole Bass in the same shot, so that nullifies the hotness.
I like Jillian Hall's gimmick and she sorta reminds me of someone I know.

[Fire-Babe]

i'm picking wrestling over non wrestling (and only secondarily hotness factor), so it sounds like Jillian is my choice this round, unless whoever nominated JSC can convince me otherwise.

[Demko]

Completely agreed, FW. I'm more interesting in wrestling than standing around trying to look hot.

[Batman]

I'd be willing to vote for either of them based on hotness OR ability.

I'll abstain.

[Byrntrigan]

Jasmine St. Claire is hot for a porn star. But a little part of me thinks that part of that hotness is her doing things for us to watch on DVD, not just general OMG she's hot or attractiveness.

Jillian isn't that pretty, but she has a certain "normal world" hotness and doesn't look fake hot IMO.

[DevSop]

Except for the massively fake tits, dxb?

[Lucky]

"She may have fake boobs but she's not attractive enough to be intimidating to us normal guys!"

or

"Hey, I could nail that girl with big funbags!"

I voted Jillian because Jasmine always had that icky factor. I think she's arguably more attractive than Jillian but icky. And I don't mean the porn thing or the fact that she's famous for being done up the ass by 100 men in the row or something. I mean she slept with Blue Meanie.

[DevSop]

EXALT!

[bdbdbd]

I can't see myself voting for either of these. Can I sell my vote?

[Byrntrigan]

Ahh, throw the ass fuckee a sympathy vote. 'Cause she may be the reciepient of a shutout.

[Byrntrigan]

Apr 5, 2008 13:34:11 GMT -5 DevSop said:

Except for the massively fake tits, dxb?

yes. But massively fake tits don't bother me as much. In the face she looks like a normal broad.

[BC]

Normally, I'd vote for Jillian, but I like Jasmine, so I'll throw her the sympathy vote.

I'd say I'd throw her a bone, but that would just be too easy.

[salmonjunkie]

Jasmine St. Claire is fucking gross.

And she's NOT hot for a porn star. She's only famous because she gangbanged 300 guys on camera.

[Lucky]

This baby locked up last night and it was a mercy kill. Jillian may not be a model but she had more than enough to put Jasmine down. Porn girl goes home, wannabe pop star heads into the big field to take on her fellow WWE Diva Mickie James.