[Mr. Dashbee]

Solly's Riverbottom Nightmare Band- Axl Rose (vocals), Angus Young (guitar), Pete Townshend (utility 1 - vocals, guitar), Keith Moon (drums), Geddy Lee (bass), Joan Jett (utility 2 - guitar, vocals)

vs.

Sportsguy’s Drunk Dead Gorgeous - Bruce Springsteen (vocals), , Billy Joe Armstrong (guitar), Stevie Wonder (utility 1 – keyboards, vocals), Taylor Swift (utility 2 – guitar, vocals), Gene Simmons (bass), Rick Allen (drums)

Please keep in mind that set-lists were optional. Please vote based on the artists drafted!

MTA: My bad, the seeds didn't make it into the poll question for this one. I think by now everyone knows Solly is #1 & Sporty is #16.

[DevSop]

Down with Solly.

[Lou]

If you're down with P, well then you're down with me.

Sorry.

Springsteen and Wonder, again.

[creepy]

Love that Rentals song.


Why would anybody not vote Solly here?

[Deleted]

Riverbottom Nightmare Band

[Jobber Blitz]

Solly. Duh.

[Tommy]

May 12, 2009 3:16:21 GMT -5 creepy said:

Why would anybody not vote Solly here?

May 12, 2009 1:23:24 GMT -5 DevSop said:

Down with Solly.

That.

[The Jewish Cunthead]

Sorry - are we voting for the band or who drafted it? I forgot.

[Tommy]

May 12, 2009 9:56:39 GMT -5 The Jewish Cunthead said:

Sorry - are we voting for the band or who drafted it? I forgot.

Who drafted it.

[The Canadian Content]

May 12, 2009 1:23:24 GMT -5 DevSop said:

Down with Solly.

I misread this. I thought Sop meant "I'm down with Solly," or "I like Solly's band." To vote against Solly's band because he's won a bunch of these things is retarded. Why should he be penalized for having a mix of good taste in things and an uncanny knowledge of what others on the board will vote for?

In closing, grow up.

[Tommy]

May 12, 2009 10:01:02 GMT -5 The Canadian Content said:

May 12, 2009 1:23:24 GMT -5 DevSop said:

Down with Solly.

I misread this. I thought Sop meant "I'm down with Solly," or "I like Solly's band." To vote against Solly's band because he's won a bunch of these things is retarded. Why should he be penalized for having a mix of good taste in things and an uncanny knowledge of what others on the board will vote for?

In closing, grow up.

Sportsguy is going to get crushed anyway.

In closing, it's a joke. Don't take showdowns so damned seriously.

[Byrntrigan]

Solly. I wonder if my band would have matched up well.

[Lucky]

I have the same reaction I had to sportsguy's group in the last matchup. Solly's group looks like it would probably mesh together and might make a better band... but I couldn't live with myself if I skipped sportsguy's whether they sink or swim. Solly's? Meh, I could live without seeing it.

[Batman]

May 12, 2009 11:42:10 GMT -5 Lucky said:

I have the same reaction I had to sportsguy's group in the last matchup. Solly's group looks like it would probably mesh together and might make a better band... but I couldn't live with myself if I skipped sportsguy's whether they sink or swim. Solly's? Meh, I could live without seeing it.

I'd hate to miss Springsteen and Wonder together, but their rhythm section not being up to snuff compared to who they usually play with--much less having all of time to choose from--kind of sinks it for me. Going with Axl and Townshend.

Rick Allen and Gene Simmons would be a fine rhythm section for a hard rock band, but for Wonder and Springsteen? Nah.

[BC]

Gene Simmons + Taylor Swift + Rick Allen.

A demon, a popstar, & a one armed drummer. It's like a circus act, I love it.

Plus Axl's a douche.