[Loki]

Voting will end on or about 3/2. Maybe sooner. Who knows?

This poll is now open!

[The Canadian Content]

I used to love Gargoyles. If they only get one vote, it's mine.

[Krydor]

They get my vote because Underdog essentially blew.

[Chris Eco]

Underdog did not blow. It was a quietly brilliant show with the most direct plots ever. No, it's not the most engaging show ever as an adult, but through a children's lens, I consider it up there. And the rhyming!



"I want a small bomb to carry around with me."

[williamssl]

Hey Lucky - ya voted in this one? If not.....Underdog is being released as a live action movie this year.

One of the stars is Susie Castillo.

She was Miss USA 2003.

[Lucky]

That is an enticing arguement. However my "Hot Chicks" rule is a Live Action one. I suppose live action versions of cartoons could make an exception but it hadn't come up until now. And really, its in the case of showdowns I don't care about. I do have opinions of both shows in this one.

I voted Gargoyles. Because I have no true recollection of enjoying Underdog as a kid and I just watched that youtube video and it did nothing for me.

Now I'm off to google image search Susie Castillo.

[The Jewish Cunthead]

This is why I'm voting for Underdog.



Underdog Lady from the classic Ch. 9 Stern show.

[Deleted]

luckylopez said:

Now I'm off to google image search Susie Castillo.

Oh, you'll wanna do more than just Google her.

[docx]

I watched Underdog. I enjoyed Underdog. Gargoyles, you are no Underdog.

[Krydor]

That's right, because Gargoyles had, you know, a point to it and was well animated.

Then again, based on the fact that a mouse pretending to be James Bond is the cat's ass, why should I be surprised that a dog pretending to be Superman is so well loved?

[Evil Scotty]

for all you bastards that love underdog more www.apple.com/trailers/disney/underdog/hd/

[Lucky]

Wow. That looks like some real crap right there.

I was pretty apathetic to this one when I voted Gargoyles but the more I think about it the more I agree with Krydor. I've watched a couple of Underdog cartoons on Youtube this week. Its pretty basic fare for that style/type of cartoon. Simple story, silly character, maybe charming to a kid but lacking any real value as an adult. MAYBE I liked Underdog when I was a kid. I can't remember. But if I did, it sure didn't last. I watched Gargoyles as a kid and loved it. Rushed home after school to see it and that continued into high school. Then a couple of years ago when my cable expanded to digital I found it airing at 11 PM or so every weekday (along with X-Men) and started watching. I still dug it and was tuning in many nights to keep following with the story. Gargoyles worked. It was good animation, good stories, and a serial. And it worked for at least 3 age periods as best as I can tell. Underdog is just your typical short, silly, toon.

At this rate I'm not going to like any cartoons in the 2nd round.

[Loki]

Sure you will. Next round is when the big guns come out. GI Joe, Animaniacs, Transformers and Silly Symphonies all get past their byes.

Not that bold of a prediction, but I say that Bugs Bunny and crew will win the whole thing.

[Loki]

And this is now CLOSED. Underdog has pulled away witha 10-8 win.

[Krydor]

And baby Jesus cried.

[salmonjunkie]

Boo. Gargoyles was AWESOME. Underdog just had a cool tagline, but I can't say I remember a single episode of it.

This is almost as heinous as JL losing to freaking Hong Kong Phooey.