For Hodgey Umaga/Warrior would be a glorious train wreck, and Kofi/Dolph v. Pretty Cool has a ton of potential on the undercard. But the top 4 on Eric's card won me over, and Naito/Viking is probably going to steal the show.

I really love both of these cards. I think the “story” Solly has been telling with RTruth vs Hogan has been super fun and hilarious and that may be enough to tip the scales. But I am equally impressed with Fishy putting Tajiri in the main event against Steamboat.

Solly for now but I may change it before it’s all said and done.

I NEED A HERO!

Seriously, Eco has a card I would vote for a lot.

I think Austin vs Orton would have been an amazing match, and I’m super proud of my women’s division. I have some fun Card 5 ideas that I’d love to share! Plus I don’t think I’ve beaten Eco since 2009 in one of these things so…someone tie this bad boy up!

He worked twice at Mania IX

Among my favorite cards all around this time. Hodgey is such a clean mix of interesting matchups and Leo has really run this gimmick to perfection. Tipping my hat to our fearless showdown runner this time.

I would absolutely watch the jerk match (and I love the Miz in a main event on principle), but SG is so peak SG that I can't help but admire it.

It takes some effort for me to vote for a WarGames match, but I'll pull the trigger here, though I'm looking forward to Trick v Drew when it happens (and Dijak v Ali is awesome and would have happened if Retribution got any kind of proper story arc).

I love the Stephanie's Honor Match

I like the flag match and Fantastics vs reDRagon would rule. they make me lean 5ifth.

David vs DiBiase? I didn't even need to read the rest to know where my vote was going.

Cole

World Wrestling Federation presents “Wrestlemania”
Live from Allegiant Stadium, Las Vegas, Nevada

Commentators: Vic Joseph & Byron Saxton

WWF Championship
“The Final Boss” The Rock (Champion) vs “The Tribal Chief” Roman Reigns

WWF Intercontinental Championship
Kazuchika Okada (Champion) vs Damien Priest

WWF Tag Team Championship
Kota Ibushi & Kushida (Champions) vs Top Flight: Darius & Dante Martin

WWF Women’s Championship
Cora Jade (Champion) vs Jamie Hayter

WWF Women’s Tag Team Championship
Nia Jax & Ava Raine vs The Unholy Union: Alba Fyre & Isla Dawn

Bayley vs Thunder Rosa

“Timeless” Toni Storm vs Hikaru Shida

Ricky Starks vs Logan Paul

Santos Escobar vs Rey Fenix

Firefly Funhouse Match
Uncle Howdy vs Orange Cassidy

Tag Team Battle Royale
JD McDonagh & Killian Dain vs Hikuleo & Thamiko Fatu w/ Rikishi vs A Town Down Under: Austin Theory & Grayson Waller vs Wyatt 6: Joe Gacy & Rowan w/ Dexter Lumis vs Angel Garza & Humberto Carillo vs Grizzled Young Veterans: James Drake & Zack Gibson vs Dark Order: Evil Uno & Alex Reynolds w/Colt Cabana
-------------------------------------------------------------

Cletus
No card submitted by deadline. 

Posedown~! Talk about a blast from the past.

Te Gauntlet and three women's matches tips it toward Biscuits a bit for me, but I also like the attention to detail with the blocks for Dash, and the top of Dash's card is just excellent.

Wyatt 6 vs. Dark Order took some incredible effort, and I love the multi-man style of Cole's card, but Eric's card is basically everyone I just missed on my draft board in really fresh matchups. Eric, but much more narrowly than I expected.

Two great cards, but I love that Solly is actually really going for it this year while still mixing in the humor and his personal favorites. Plus, I'm looking forward to the next Hogan escalation.

Matte's card is great, I appreciate staying competitive with it.

I think by definition the triple threat needs Keith Lee to be a triple threat ;-) But no, I'm just overly sensitive about repeating real-life matches, even if Jey Uso v. Daniel Bryan happened well before Jey Uso became the super-over character he is now.

The tag matches are strong, but it's just a lot of sameness.

Triple H vs. Blanchard could be match of the night. TLC is a nice mix eras. Dragunov vs. Hart can be a five star classic.

Main event is straight fire. Spears vs. Park in a chairs match is fun. That fourway with PAC, Garvin, Duggan and Reed feels like a train wreck I'd totally watch. Mangum and Nikita vs. ME is just good old fashioned fun.

Matt Morgan is underrated. He wasn't used right in WWE. So him vs. Piper has me intrigued. I'm picturing early UT against Steamboat with Ricky having his working boots on. Chyna vs. Ripley could have main evented.

Dev has some solid stuff with the tag title match and death match being my favorites.

It's not mandatory but I personally give bonus points when comparing cards to whoever uses more of their roster.

Can't believe how competitive a card Fifth put together, so that's my tiebreak, though Hodgey's card is basically a list of my favorites that I never draft because I worry they're not others' favorites (especially the TLC competitors and the women's trios) - well done all around.