Great pick! The only reason I didn't yake him several rounds ago is that he doesn't fit the theme of any of my teams, but definately one of my favorites.
If thats who you were scared of me taking, there's almost zero chance of that ever happening. Near the bottom of my favorite characters from that show. Though as a villain, she may have been useful.
Honestly, what do we disagree about. It’s a clearly very exaggerated version of real events. I just read through the Wikipedia page of the real Holliday and let’s just go with, he probably killed upwards of 20-25 people in the movie and in reality, maybe only killed 3-5. The biggest fight in the move, Ringo, is almost 100% fictional since Doc wasn’t even likely in the state when Ringo died. I’m just not sure how he’d be invalid based on the Fictional Portrayal rule I have on the first post.
Post by Cliffsnotes on Jul 13, 2022 16:46:24 GMT -5
OK. Doc Holliday isn't a critical pick for me. Pretty much the sole reason for drafting him was so that his teammate/leader Eric Cartman could continuously say "I'm your Huckleberry" over and over. (Also, everyone who read that sentence is saying "I'm your Huckleberry" in Cartman's voice).
So if there are two vetoes on this pick, and nobody minds, I will void that pick and swap it out for another character selected solely because I want Eric Cartman to say his catchphrase.
OK. Doc Holliday isn't a critical pick for me. Pretty much the sole reason for drafting him was so that his teammate/leader Eric Cartman could continuously say "I'm your Huckleberry" over and over. (Also, everyone who read that sentence is saying "I'm your Huckleberry" in Cartman's voice).
So if there are two vetoes on this pick, and nobody minds, I will void that pick and swap it out for another character selected solely because I want Eric Cartman to say his catchphrase.
You can re-pick if you want, but I’m really not seeing an issue with the pick. But if you do re-pick, I’ll take Holliday (Tombstone) off the board since it wouldn’t be fair to you, but the movie itself would still be eligible for other characters unless I get a solid reason that it’s not a clearly fictionalized version of the story and characters.