[Byrntrigan]

Edge & Christian


versus

The Dudley Boyz



Please feel free to post youtubes of matches as well as your arguments for or against the team of your choice! Polls will lock approximately in 1 week at midnight.

[National Champion Chris Cole]

E&C over Harts in the finals for me!

[The Jewish Cunthead]

Someone convince me.

[Courtney]

Aug 21, 2008 8:05:45 GMT -5 National Champion Chris Cole said:

E&C over Harts in the finals for me!

Ditto.

[Moosehead Jack]

Edge and Christian may both be better individual wrestlers, but to me the Duds were a better tag team

[Eric O'Mac]

Ironically, I'd love either a Hart Foundation vs. E&C or Road Warrior vs. Dudley Boyz final, but not Harts vs. Dudleys or Road Warriors vs. E&C, in terms of wrestling matches and such. However, I'm voting the Dudley's here, because, as Moose said, they are the better team, even if Edge and Christian are better talents.

[The Jewish Cunthead]

Aug 21, 2008 8:41:10 GMT -5 Moosehead Jack said:

Edge and Christian may both be better individual wrestlers, but to me the Duds were a better tag team

OK that convinced me. Thanks Chuckles.

[gooker]

Wow, I've missed out on this contest till now and my vote just seems to have broken a tie. I voted Dudz. As someone said above, I love E & C as individual wrestlers and as a tag team, but you really can't match what the Dudleyz have done together throughout their career.

[National Champion Chris Cole]

I'm not going to penalize E&C for being great singles stars. Bubba & Devon can't get over on their own so they continue to be a great team. E&C were in my opinion the BEST overall team during the peak run of WWF tag teams. They would stil be the best tag team today if they were still a team. The were great in the ring and more versatile then the Duds. They could brawl, do hardcore brawls, keep up with high flyers. And they worked the mic great as faces and especially excellent as heels.

And to this day when my wife or I smell something bad we always say "That reeks and not of awesomeness." We use that a lot with the baby.

[Eric O'Mac]

I'm far from penalizing Edge and Christian for being singles stars. I think they were a great tag team - but I think the Dudleyz were just a little bit better.

Sure, if Edge and Christian were still a tag team today, they'd be the best or one of the best, but you can say that about almost any team in this showdown. I'm not giving this to the Dudleyz due to their longevity as a tag team or their failure to get over as singles, but, simply put, they are better. By a very slim margin. (IMO)

[National Champion Chris Cole]

If you truly feel they were better then by all means vote for Duds. I think I gave some pretty good reasons in favor of E&C as a team.

And if E&C lose this round I'll be disappointted but not overly so. I really do enjoy the Duds and think very highly of them. But E&C are number one on my list and they were number one long before they sniffed the Main Event as singles wrestlers.

[gooker]

I basically went with who is more decorated in this round, since both teams were beyond awesome in their prime. However, the Dudz have held titles in so many different leagues multiple times - ECW, WWE, WCW, TNA...(even though, granted, some of that was due to the Invasion). Still, they accomplished more.

Unfortunately, if it comes down to them vs. the Hart Foundation in the Finals, that won't help them with me.

[salmonjunkie]

Man this is hard. Both these teams were my favorites at the time they were killing it in WWF, and the Dudleys were neck and neck with the Eliminators as my favorite ECW tag team.

So there's only one way to decide this, since it's neck and neck. Who had the better tag team finisher?

It's the Dudleys.