[williamssl]

[glow=red,2,300]THIS POLL IS NOT YET OPEN - IT WILL OPEN THE EVENING OF WED, DEC 13. USE THIS THREAD NOW TO CONVINCE YOUR FELLOW PUNSTERS WHO THEY SHOULD VOTE FOR[/glow]

Our next batch of matchups features the #4's vs. the #5's, so technically these should be the closest round 1 bouts (although it didn't play out that way in the Superhero Showdown....).

Here we have Marvel's #4 the Green Goblin vs. DC's #5 Catwoman (note: CatWOMAN, Loki, not CatMAN.)

Their wiki's:

Green Goblin

Catwoman

If the Willem Dafoe or Halle Berry movie versions of these characters are all you know of either of these villans, please read their wiki's!!!

A few things:

• You're voting for who you think is the greatest supervillain, or the greater of the two. It's not about who could beat the other up.
  
• You can only vote once.
  
• The poll will open Wednesday evening, December 13 and close at 2 pm Eastern on Sun, November, er make that Dec 17, so have your vote in by then for it to count.
  

[williamssl]

Look - I said I was gonna be consistent in my voting and logic with how I handled the Hulk vs. Wonder Woman (Lynda Carter) matchup.

So here's part 1 in my case for Catwoman. Lady and Gentlemen - the incomparable Julie Newmar as Catwoman.

[Loki]

Great picture.

"Hey, baby, check out my Bat Missile!"

[National Champion Chris Cole]

Tough call. I'm a big fan of both. Right now I'm leaning towards Catwoman though. I really like that bottom picture.

[Batman]

I'm definitely going with Green Goblin. He's not one of my favorites or anything, but he was Spider-man's #1 arch-enemy--he killed Gwen!

[The Canadian Content]

metallikid said:

I really like that bottom picture.

Hey look, a pun.

[Deleted]

A very awesome pun. And while I love that pic (see what kind of attention a few pics on ehre could get you, court?!?) my vote must go to Green Goblin.

Anybody taken a gander at the Ultimate version?

[Lucky]

I hate the Ultimate version myself. Not much love for the 616 version either. Movie version might be my favorite.

Catwoman's getting my vote almost by default. I just don't like Goblin.

And Catwoman's hot.

[salmonjunkie]

As a villain, in a sense of the term, Green Goblin is awesome. The legacy of his character in the comic book is awesome. His movie character as portrayed by Dafoe is awesome. \ How he affects Spider-Man's life is awesome. That both Norman and Harry tatke this mantle for two completely different reasons is awesome. Green Goblin is awesome.

But Tex has a very convincing arguement.

[williamssl]

Looks like my logic may be having some influence.

Part 2 in the case for Catwoman - more of the incomparable Julie Newmar (although nothing as good as the bottom pic.).

[The Canadian Content]

Hey, why can't I vote?

[williamssl]

Now open for business! Unless you're Krydor.

[salmonjunkie]

I still can't make a decision.... Green Goblin is Spidey's ultimate baddy, but I've wanted to fuck a couple versions of Catwoman - namely, Julie Newmar, Michelle Pfieffer, Halle Berry (she sucks shit, but I'd still fuck the shit out of her), and a few girl-geeks I'd see as comic cons who actually could pull the costume off.

Actually, let's retract that last one. I don't remember any who could pull it off.

I'm voting Villains. You shouldn't want to have to fuck the villain. You should only be fearful of the villain.

[williamssl]

So you won't vote for Catwoman even though you want to fuck her but you will vote for Poison Ivy because her power is making you want to fuck her. Did I get that right?

[salmonjunkie]

Well, I'd have voted Catwoman over Red Skull as well. But neither over Goblin. Skull's just a nazi. OOOOH SCARY!

And Poison Ivy KILLS YOU by making you want to fuck her. Catwoman's hotness makes ME, SALMONJUNKIE want to fuck her. All that does is keep Bruce Wayne from putting her in jail.

[williamssl]

So you won't vote for Catwoman even though you want to fuck her but you will vote for Poison Ivy because her power is making you want to fuck her. Did I get that right?

[salmonjunkie]

Um... it's about their respective opponents.

Poison Ivy is making me vote for her. Goddamn phermones power.

[williamssl]

Nooooo. Catwoman needs more votes. More. Look at the pictures. Oh hell, here's more of different folks as Catwoman:





Oh shit...what's she doing as Catwoman???? Craaaaap. There goes the vote.

[The Jewish Cunthead]

I'm sold... I voted for Catwoman cuz Stone Cold says so!

[The Canadian Content]

I think Catwoman's more recent good-guy phase will decide this for me. GG = permanently evil. Catwoman = sometimes evil. GG is a better "villain" than Catwoman.

[williamssl]

Damn you people!!! If there's anyone who hasn't voted, vote for Catwoman...because Eddie Guerrero would have wanted you to.

[Deleted]

I hate Eddie Guerrero.

[salmonjunkie]

psychofish said:

I think Catwoman's more recent good-guy phase will decide this for me. GG = permanently evil. Catwoman = sometimes evil. GG is a better "villain" than Catwoman.

Quoted for truth

[williamssl]

williamssl said:

Quoted for hotness

[williamssl]

Ugh. If there is ONE person out there who hasn't voted...please vote. And if you are open to argument, please consider these in addition to the multiple other photographic evidence datapoints that have been submitted in the case for Catwoman.






But regradless, vote. And thanks.